Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
yoshinkan · Yoshinkan Aikido List
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Show off your group to the world. Share a photo of your group with us.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Aikido as a "martial" art   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #7581 of 8914 |
I have question that has long since plagued my mind. How do you, as
Yoshinkan practitioners, reconcile the fact that you devote so much of
your time to a martial art that isn't really 'martial'. I mean, we
understand that the training curriculum is quite standardized with a
strict focus on kihon, but the curriculum does not have any venue for
actually testing the effectiveness of aikido in violent situations. We
train the kihon, develop the principals, and improve our timing and
power through jiyu waza. But how do you reconcile the fact that this is
a 'martial' art without any means of testing its martial quality. This
certainly isn't a dig at aikido, considering that I practice it quite
regularly and have been for over a decade. I'm just curious to see how
the wider aikido community reconciles this aspect of the art. Or is
this aspect of it even important to many of you?

CBB







Thu Mar 23, 2006 7:35 pm

captain_blac...
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #7581 of 8914 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

I have question that has long since plagued my mind. How do you, as Yoshinkan practitioners, reconcile the fact that you devote so much of your time to a...
captain_black_belt
captain_blac...
Offline Send Email
Mar 23, 2006
7:37 pm

I believe Aikido is a budo and not a martial art in the usual way we think of that term. As a budo it is a "way" of life organized around martial principles. ...
Shumaker, Gordon
gordon.shumaker@...
Send Email
Mar 23, 2006
7:51 pm

Heyas, To add to the thread Aikido is a martial art.Depends on how you train as individuals,and your instructors lesson plans.Just to add fuel to the ...
Brown John
ronin516
Offline Send Email
Mar 23, 2006
9:54 pm

I think that many of you make great points, especially Gordon's distinction between Budo and martial art. I agree that Yoshinkan can be used effectively in...
captain_black_belt
captain_blac...
Offline Send Email
Mar 23, 2006
11:00 pm

Hmm....one of the age old questions. I wonder if this point was the very one Danial san was learning from Mr. Miagi (spelling) by painting his fence. ...
Phase of Life
phaseol
Offline Send Email
Mar 23, 2006
11:43 pm

On the contrary, I believe (caveat, only a mudansha) Yoshinkan aikido can be effectively used in a street-fight, even if only in avoiding one (as Mr. Shumaker...
Fred Calef III
cirquelar
Offline Send Email
Mar 23, 2006
8:48 pm

One further comment. Media accounts are replete with incidents in which yudansha in various martial arts have been beaten or killed by street fighters. In my...
Shumaker, Gordon
gordon.shumaker@...
Send Email
Mar 24, 2006
12:11 am

Sounds like good training! Some dojos are less "realistic." But even cops have problems when they try to use their modified Aikido techniques. A good...
Shumaker, Gordon
gordon.shumaker@...
Send Email
Mar 24, 2006
12:16 am

Mindset. The study of strict 'kihon' over the years gives you great flowing within the syllabus. That is about it. But as some people have said previously you...
Daryl Hartz
darylhartz
Offline Send Email
Mar 24, 2006
2:11 pm

There have been some interesting and insightful comments from everybody so far. But I do some further questions/clarifications; Phase: That's a nice theory,...
captain_black_belt
captain_blac...
Offline Send Email
Mar 24, 2006
3:13 pm

The testing of Aikido as a "battle worthy" martial art is not even necessary. It has been battle proven for decades has it not? To know that it works without...
Daryl Hartz
darylhartz
Offline Send Email
Mar 28, 2006
4:10 am

Fire extinguishers are absolutely "useless"until they become priceless with the outbreak of a fire......That is the way of Aikido. ...
Brown John
ronin516
Offline Send Email
Mar 28, 2006
3:10 pm

Some people seem offended to think that Aikido might be called a budo rather than a martial art. A budo is a MARTIAL way. The word "bu" in Japanese signifies...
Shumaker, Gordon
gordon.shumaker@...
Send Email
Mar 28, 2006
3:06 pm
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help