Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
scoresheet-talk · This list is to discuss matters related to Scoresheet Fantasy Baseball. Check the FAQ for posting guidelines
  • Members Only
  • Post
  • Files
  • Photos
  • Links
  • Database
  • Polls
  • Members
  • Calendar
  • Promote
  • Groups Labs (Beta)
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Show off your group to the world. Share a photo of your group with us.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

   Messages Help
Message #
Search:
Advanced
Trade Lopsided?   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #53963 of 87686 |
Re: Trade Lopsided?


-If not vetoable,its close to it.The Schilling,Willis side is much
better...Randy-- In scoresheet-talk@yahoogroups.com, Michael Agnew
<thewildeboys@s...> wrote:
> This trade recently went down in an NL perpetual league I'm in,
with
> mixed reviews from others in the league. It's been branded from
vetoable
> to no big deal. What's your take on it?
>
> Curt Schilling, Dontrelle Willis, Round 18 for
> Russ Ortiz, Joe Kennedy, Cesar Izturis
Tue Feb 1, 2005 3:14 pm

Show Message Option
dlhs73
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward 		Message #53963 of 87686 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

This trade recently went down in an NL perpetual league I'm in, with mixed reviews from others in the league. It's been branded from vetoable to no big deal.... 		Michael Agnew
wildeboy2002
Offline Send Email 		Feb 1, 2005
1:48 pm

That is one of the most loopside trades I have seen no matter how you look at it. Trade 2 quality startes and a pick for 3 non-keeper players. Why do you...
JFinneganJr
Offline Send Email 		Feb 1, 2005
2:10 pm

Agree. It's a total give-away. ... you...
garthhewitt
Offline Send Email 		Feb 1, 2005
2:25 pm

I agree, too. I'm generally hesitant to brand a trade vetoable, but this is just ridiculous. ... how ... in, ... from...
lepton65
Offline Send Email 		Feb 1, 2005
2:47 pm

This trade is vetoable, IMO. Kennedy and Izturis aren't keepers. Schilling and Willis are top tier SPs. ... Joseph S Sherman jssherm@......
Joseph S Sherman
jssherman27
Offline Send Email 		Feb 1, 2005
4:43 pm

I agree with the consensus. But this summed up my feelings best. How could the guy getting the round 18 for these three have the nerve to ask for Schilling...
Bill Sanders
ss643_dp
Offline Send Email 		Feb 2, 2005
7:36 am

i agree, I had the same argument about the MET FAN and her trades ... How could ... for ... that the ... Willis ... appear ... the ... from...
pcuoccio
Offline Send Email 		Feb 2, 2005
11:46 am

i think Met Fan was in everybody's league at one time or another... she was quite out of her mind when it came to trade offers... ... ...
Ron Masztak
rjmasztak
Offline Send Email 		Feb 2, 2005
1:03 pm

Somebody got hosed? How could the guy getting Schilling and Willis actually have the nerve to take a R18 pick also? I'm not a big believer in vetoing trades...
kwarrenca
Offline Send Email 		Feb 1, 2005
2:21 pm

When one side of a trade gets the two top players AND the pick, I get nervous....
Greg Hardy
nbtbird23
Offline Send Email 		Feb 1, 2005
2:37 pm

I'm with others who say they are hesitant to call any trade without merit. There are a lot of reasons a trade can be good, despite an apparent difference in...
Danny Rowe
danny_rowe
Offline Send Email 		Feb 1, 2005
3:14 pm

-If not vetoable,its close to it.The Schilling,Willis side is much better...Randy-- In scoresheet-talk@yahoogroups.com, Michael Agnew ... with ... vetoable...
dlhs73
Offline Send Email 		Feb 1, 2005
3:17 pm

My first thought was vetoable, but now I don't even think it's so bad. Schilling is a crossover, so that reduces his value. He's also hurt, while Ortiz is...
Ari
evergreen_1979
Offline Send Email 		Feb 1, 2005
3:33 pm

I think it is far more lopsided than you say, Ari. Willis has been as good or better by all the most important statistical measures the past two years than...
John Carter
slicksilksox
Offline Send Email 		Feb 1, 2005
4:30 pm

I don't think Ortiz is a keeper right now. The 3 most valuable pieces of this trade are all on one side of the trade. ... bad. ... hurt, ... be a ... him ... ...
e_hunke
Offline Send Email 		Feb 1, 2005
5:26 pm

Well said. ... forward ... regress. ... take ... from...
JFinneganJr
Offline Send Email 		Feb 1, 2005
5:42 pm

I personally don't believe the trade is vetoable. Short term, the Schilling, Willis side gets the nod...Long term baring injury, Ortiz, Kennedy and Izturis...
Donald Browning
dragonsgm2003
Offline Send Email 		Feb 1, 2005
3:31 pm

Ugh... one of the best pitchers in modern history, a future ace (maybe) in Willis, AND a top 25 pick... in exchange for a two below replacement level innings...
Anthony
ds_music_now
Offline Send Email 		Feb 1, 2005
5:08 pm

If he has any players left, I'd be looking to deal for sure....
kwarrenca
Offline Send Email 		Feb 1, 2005
5:33 pm

This is a horrible deal except fpr the guy getting the best 2 players and the pick. ... with ... vetoable...
ojones84
Offline Send Email 		Feb 1, 2005
6:04 pm

terrible deal - i'd love to be on the curt side of it... ... http://us.click.yahoo.com/6iY7fA/5WnJAA/Y3ZIAA/v6bplB/TM ... __________________________________ Do...
Ron Masztak
rjmasztak
Offline Send Email 		Feb 1, 2005
6:41 pm

Huh? If you really have crossover issues (ie: Schilling), I'd still have to say...huh? Trade one the best current pitchers, and one of the better young...
Mark Smith
pnkflyd68
Offline Send Email 		Feb 1, 2005
7:03 pm

I would vote to overturn the trade ... with ... vetoable...
pcuoccio
Offline Send Email 		Feb 1, 2005
8:56 pm
< Prev Topic  |  Next Topic >
Message #
Search:
Advanced
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help