Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
chainguard · Bicycle Advocacy
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Show off your group to the world. Share a photo of your group with us.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
File - List Policies and Guidelines   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #22803 of 28251 |
Re: [CG] Scandinavian study of bike-transit competition?

Sorry, I can't help with the citation, but after hearing a
presentation by a Vancouver, BC-area transportation planner (Gavin
Davidson) who works for the transportation authority Translink in
2004, requiring university students to purchase bus passes as part of
their student fees definitely has an effect on cycling, downward, as a
way of getting to the campus.

It makes sense to me. Both cycling and transit are (practically)
single-traveler modes used to cover distances which would be too far
to walk; if you tip the scales in favour of one mode, the other will
suffer. (Could you imagine what would happen if free transit, from
anywhere to anywhere, were provided in your community? Do we think
people would still commute by bike to work, other than people
committed to exercising?)

For short commutes, I would expect cycling will compete with transit;
for longer commutes, transit competes with motor vehicles.
(Realistically, cycling doesn't compete with motoring--in practical
terms, you just cannot do the same things with bicycles that you can
do with cars, e.g. carrying passengers, keeping cargo secure, arriving
at a destination clean and dry.)

A lot of people involved with cycling advocacy discussions often talk
about transit (buses, trains) as being an aid to the good fight
against the single-occupant motor vehicle, but the negative effect
transit has on cycling is usually not seen through the green glasses
of anti-motoring.

Anyway, I hope someone can help Wayne with finding the reference and
not be too distracted by my opinions here.

--
Michael Poplawski
Victoria, BC Canada

On 1/3/07, Wayne Pein <wpein@...> wrote:
>
> Does anyone know of the online source for a Scandinavian study of
> transport mode choice that showed that transit is the biggest competitor
> of cycling? I seem to recall that someone on this list posted a link
> several years ago, but I haven't been able to find anything.



Wed Jan 3, 2007 9:29 pm

michaelpopla...
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #22803 of 28251 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

Does anyone know of the online source for a Scandinavian study of transport mode choice that showed that transit is the biggest competitor of cycling? I seem...
Wayne Pein
wawa42p
Offline Send Email
Jan 3, 2007
9:02 pm

Sorry, I can't help with the citation, but after hearing a presentation by a Vancouver, BC-area transportation planner (Gavin Davidson) who works for the...
Michael Poplawski
michaelpopla...
Offline Send Email
Jan 3, 2007
9:40 pm

... No need to imagine free transit. We have had it here in Chapel Hill, NC for a few years now. It has killed cycling, but I don't have numbers. ... Most...
Wayne Pein
wawa42p
Offline Send Email
Jan 4, 2007
4:28 am

... This is a question that involves utilization, the nature of the community serviced, wide ranging sets of government subsidies and edicts, etc. , etc... ...
Kenneth O'Brien
kob22225
Offline Send Email
Jan 7, 2007
2:52 pm

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Jan 15, 2007
2:34 am

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Jan 29, 2007
2:54 am

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Feb 12, 2007
12:48 am

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Feb 26, 2007
1:46 am

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Mar 12, 2007
2:42 am

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Mar 26, 2007
2:03 am

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Apr 9, 2007
1:12 am

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Apr 22, 2007
8:32 pm

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
May 6, 2007
7:46 pm

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
May 20, 2007
8:30 pm

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Jun 3, 2007
8:19 pm

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Jun 17, 2007
7:28 pm

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Jul 1, 2007
7:01 pm

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Jul 15, 2007
7:10 pm

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Jul 29, 2007
9:01 pm

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Aug 12, 2007
7:10 pm

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Aug 26, 2007
7:14 pm

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Sep 9, 2007
7:14 pm

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Sep 23, 2007
7:17 pm

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Oct 7, 2007
7:44 pm

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Oct 21, 2007
7:24 pm

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Nov 4, 2007
8:07 pm

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Nov 18, 2007
9:00 pm

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Dec 2, 2007
9:41 pm

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Dec 16, 2007
9:01 pm

================================== THE CHAINGUARD LIST IS NOT INTENDED AS A CHAT ROOM, FORUM OR BULLETIN BOARD FOR BICYCLING CHIT-CHAT OR DISCUSSION OF...
chainguard@yahoogroup...
Send Email
Dec 30, 2007
9:02 pm
 First  |  |  Last 
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help