Re: [Bodybuilding for Men] creatine and my son's death
Although I agree that that there is not know evidence that creatine causes agression, etc., I must admit that I did feel agressive while using creatine. Once I stopped, I seemed better. I was not using any type of steriods at the time; a friend of mine experienced the same thing with creatine.
--- On Sat, 4/18/09, Michael Allen <mja94116@...> wrote:
From: Michael Allen <mja94116@...> Subject: Re: [Bodybuilding for Men] creatine and my son's death To: bodybuildingformen@yahoogroups.com Date: Saturday, April 18, 2009, 6:57 PM
I am sorry for your loss. I assume you got this group reference from your son's Yahoo account.
As far as I know, there is no record of any behavioural changes from use of creatine. Perhaps some group members with medical research or other specialised knowledge on the subject can comment on this. However, there is some thought that use of steroids may cause exactly the kind of behavioural changes you describe in some people. There is a term for it: "roid rage." Whether or not there is a possible causal relationship between steroids and behavioural changes is disputed and perhaps not proven, but it does make some sense. Steroids in some ways have similar effects to testesterone, the prescence of which may have a connection to male aggressiveness. Some bodybuilders use testesterone itself as well. And of course two things happening at the same time does not in any conclusive way establish a causal link, and less so if no mechanism can be suggested. Furthermore, your son
probably started using other supplements, higher protein intake, etc. at around the same time as starting to use creatine. However, I don't think there is any evidence that there are any other particularly likely culprits associated with bodybuilding other than possibly steroids or testosterone. Again, perhaps other group members might have helpful comments. --- On Fri, 4/17/09, judy_cournoyer <judy_cournoyer@ yahoo.com> wrote:
From: judy_cournoyer <judy_cournoyer@ yahoo.com> Subject: [Bodybuilding for Men] creatine and my son's death To: bodybuildingformen@ yahoogroups. com Date: Friday, April 17, 2009, 5:09 AM
I am the mother of a 29 year old son who just lost his life because of creatine use. PLEASE heed this warning. Creatine can cause psychosis. When he started using this supplement we noticed a change in his personality. He became more aggressive. Eventually he became paranoid, could not sleep, and eventually met a very violent death going over 100 mph down a highway because "some people were after him". This supplement is NOT good for you, people. My son had his whole life ahead of him, and now he is gone. While it may occur "naturally" in the body, the dosage you ingest is NOT normal. The body secretes creatinine for a reason. It's toxic.
I am the mother of a 29 year old son who just lost his life because of creatine use. PLEASE heed this warning. Creatine can cause psychosis. When he started...
Dear Judy I am sorry for you lost I must disagree with you on using creatine.I use creatine as my daily supplement during my work outs and I am currenly 50 yrs...
... WTF how old were you when you had the kid, or was he driving at 12 something doesn't add up lady, and you blame creatine, not only that are you physic as...
From what I can gather, that sad departed kid may also be suffering from either drug-use (ketamine or ICE may induce paranoid delusions) or also some form of...
I am sorry for your loss. I assume you got this group reference from your son's Yahoo account. As far as I know, there is no record of any behavioural...
Michael I do agree with your comments as well some thing just does not add up in this story at . I don't think creatine was the only factor that there was more...
Look this story up on google and I would bet a million bucks you'll find it's spam. There are people out there ready to attack any chemical and any business ...
I'm sorry for your loss as well but I want to believe that your son was taking something you were not aware of ; because i`ve used creatine supplements for a...
Although I agree that that there is not know evidence that creatine causes agression, etc., I must admit that I did feel agressive while using creatine. Once...
Thanks..no, I didn't get the site from my son. I went looking for any other information I could find. Some of the comments I'm getting are pretty mean..I'm...
I know this because he had called my sister the night before his death. He told her "Some people are after me". He drove all night long trying to keep from...
I'm truly very sorry for your loss. Thank you for your kindness in sharing your concerns while going through such a difficult time. It's given us all something...
Thanks for your comment. I'm glad that you have no serious side effects from the use of creatine. I do know that he was also taking an energy booster, and...
I have used creatine off and on for eight years with no ill effects and some definite physical benefits. I also have seen a variety of reactions to creatine...
well Judy, once again i'm so sorry for your loss, but reading your story over and your response points to other causes ..and not creatine..5hrs of sleep in...
"I'm glad that you have no serious side effects from the use of creatine. I do know that he was also taking an energy booster, and perhaps this is why he only...
No, he wasn't on steroids. I definitely noticed that whenever he took the creatine his mood changed from a gentle, loving person into a more aggressive...
Excuse me, but isn't hydrogen-hydroxide water? ... From: Vincent Fitzpatrick <jvftzjvftz@...> Subject: Re: [Bodybuilding for Men] creatine and my son's...
Thanks for the comment. I actually spoke to an EMT who said that he's seen cases of death on several occasions due to creatine use. If nothing more, I'd...
Judy over the last few days I have been reading  the opinions and explantions of creatine use I for once use creatine as a daily use for my workouts . I also...
Judy: I am an EMT. EMT's are NOT diagnosticians. EMT's do not have access to or administer blood tests or any other such diagnostic tests. Our job is to...
 I have used Creatine for over 20 years without issue. Here is a good site with good information about side effects/risks. Death is not listed anywhere that I...
not spam. I truly am the mother of this sweet young man who died. His name was Charlie Cournoyer. You can see his obit at Smith and Walker Funeral...