Great news!  They both really deserved it.  Having Tex is almost the same as when Matiingling was there.  And, it's really great the Captain's work was recognized! --- On Tue, 11/10/09, Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@...> wrote: From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@...> Subject: [YankeesMVP1] Fwd: Jeter, Tex honored for excellent defense To: "Yankeesmvp1Group" <Yankeesmvp1@yahoogroups.com> Date: Tuesday, November 10, 2009, 5:22 PM   ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From: yankees.com <feedback@mail. mlblists. com> Date: Tue, Nov 10, 2009 at 5:11 PM Subject: Jeter, Tex honored for excellent defense To: scott.coulter2@ gmail.com Having trouble reading this email? View this email as plain text »  |  Visit yankees.com »  Forward to a friend » Mark Teixeira and Derek Jeter earned their first Gold Glove Awards since 2006. JETER, TEIXEIRA WIN GOLD GLOVE AWARDS First rings, now this. Nearly a week after leading the Yanks to their 27th title, Derek Jeter and Mark Teixeira won their fourth and third Gold Glove Awards, respectively, on Tuesday. MORE FROM YANKEES.COM » BUY GEAR NOW » NEW YORK YANKEES INFORMATION: NEWS   |   YANKEES GEAR © 2009 MLB Advanced Media, L.P. All rights reserved. All Major League Baseball trademarks and service marks used herein are the property of the applicable MLB entity. All other marks used herein are trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective owners. Please review our Privacy Policy » You received this message because you registered to receive commercial e-mail messages from yankees.com. If you no longer wish to receive commercial e-mail messages from yankees.com, please click here to unsubscribe » Postal Address: yankees.com, c/o MLB Advanced Media, L.P., 75 Ninth Avenue, 5th Floor, New York, NY 10011. -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter

 

Is today Brenda's birthday???

 

Light travels faster than sound. That is why some people appear bright until you hear them speak.

Congratulations Yankees! Championship #27!
Scott

-----Original Message-----
From: unctarheelgal@...
Sent: Tue, 10 Nov 2009 16:46:18 -0000
To: yankeesmvp1@yahoogroups.com
Subject: [YankeesMVP1] Happy BDAY Brenda!

 

Have a great Birthday Brenda! Jules

---

Free 3D Marine Aquarium Screensaver
Watch dolphins, sharks & orcas on your desktop! Check it out at www.inbox.com/marineaquarium

 

Hate to say it Red, but he has already said he does not want to negotiate, he wants to try free agency and he has said out loud to a reporter that he wants to go somewhere where he has the chance to win multiple times.  Sounds like Yankees to me.

On Tue, Nov 10, 2009 at 11:48 AM, redbug <redbug51@...> wrote:

 

I'm not saying Cervelli is mauer.  But, you never know what'll happen w/ Mauer.  He could get hurt.  He's a hometown boy who probably wants to stay w/ Mn and will give them a discount.  --- On Tue, 11/10/09, Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@...> wrote: From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@...> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@yahoogroups.com Date: Tuesday, November 10, 2009, 10:37 AM   hate to say it, but Cervelli is a good kid but he is not Joe Mauer. On Tue, Nov 10, 2009 at 10:30 AM, redbug <redbug51@yahoo. com> wrote:   Why not give Cervelli a shot while waiting to see if they want to take a shot at mauer? --- On Tue, 11/10/09, Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> wrote: From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Date: Tuesday, November 10, 2009, 6:57 AM   I just posted an article from the NYDN that makes this kind of speculation a moot point.  It details how weak this year's FA class is and how strong the one is for next year.  I think the Yankees might be best served to go with Johnny and Hideki for one more year, Jose as well, because there are guys the year after that where we will need to spend money.  Lackey might be the splash for this year because he is younger than Halladay next year we would have a shot at Joe Mauer plus a few other really good players.  I would even say fill the OF spot from within and suffer with Austin Jackson learning at the big league level if money is really an issue.  There are some good players coming up a year later. On Tue, Nov 10, 2009 at 6:15 AM, redbug <redbug51@yahoo. com> wrote:   I know he played 3rd but I can't remember his arm.  He hasn't played much outfield in recent yr's. Probably because they neeeded him at 3rd. --- On Mon, 11/9/09, Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> wrote: From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Date: Monday, November 9, 2009, 9:38 PM   I'm speaking strictly to his arm, nothing else.  He played 3rd base all season, probably one of the most demanding throwing positions on the field along with RF. On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 5:33 PM, redbug <redbug51@yahoo. com> wrote:   I'm about 5 emails behind you guys on Figgins but had one question...How's his arm?  Because it's hard to beat Johnny offensively and on the basepaths (I think his double steal was the Series).  Johnny's arm is his only majoe weakness.  If Figgins isn't a huge upgrade over Johnny in the field, why replace him? --- On Mon, 11/9/09, mikeman341@writeme. com <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote: From: mikeman341@writeme. com <mikeman341@writeme. com> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Date: Monday, November 9, 2009, 10:46 AM   Scott, You're right on both broadcasters.  Joe Morgan's 30+ years of defending his precious Reds as one of the best of all time is boring, misleading and incorrect.  Yes, they won back to back WS all those years ago, big deal.  In the ensuing time the Yanks have won er...let's see here I think the number is 7 WS titles, including 3 in a row and 4/5...but they'll never ever, ever be as good as the Reds.  Gimme a break.  I read somewhere that he is kind of hard to get along with in the prep and in the booth, I'm not surprised.   The Yanks have been preaching 'in house answers' since Cash got the promised control a few years ago.  I'd really like to see them give Pena a legit shot.  I had been eyeing JJ Hardy for a couple of years as a viable replacement for Jeter but he's off the market again.  I also like Tulo in Denver but I think he's signed long term.  I just really like the Pena option.  I'd like to see him get a real chance next year to win the job for himself.   I also like your assessment of Matsui and the comparison to Ruben Sierra.  Plus, Matsui really, really wants to come back to the Bronx.  I really like him as the DH for the next couple of years.   Mike -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 10:30 am Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   McCarver is a problem and so is Joe Morgan.  I wonder if it is because they were players and played against the Yankees for all those years?   I agree that Andy might take his glove and go home a winner, and he was one this year, that's for sure.   I'd like to see the Pena kid given a chance, I agee that as a SH he might do well for us in the 2 hole.  SH are very valuable, and I didn't notice that he had a weaker side.  He played a little OF towards the end of the season in Scranton, and that might not be a bad way to get up here.  I remember a young man named Mattingly who did it that way.  He turned out pretty good! On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 10:10 AM, <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote:   Scott, Yeah, I'd take Andy in a heartbeart over Randy.  I know Andy's family means a whole lot to him and missing his son's games is a tough one for him.  I am not at all sure he's coming back, in fact at this point, I think I'd be surprised a little bit if he does.  He wanted to pitch in the new stadium and help to bring another title here.  He accomplished what he wanted and would be leaving on an extremely high note.  I want him to come back, make no mistake about that.  I am convinced he has at least one more good season left in his arm and he could still be a terrific mentor for some of the young guys.   I like Pena at short and I can't help but wonder how he'd do in the 2 hole.  It would be a huge jump but he handles the bat well and he's a switch hitter.  I don't think we could expect much power but we have 6 other guys who supply that.  But for right now, Derek is the man at short.  Maybe he'll prove all the naysayers wrong two years running.  In the lineup, I wouldn't put him back at the 2 hole for the reason you mention...too many GIDP.   Kennedy is not flashing too bright on my radar but I do beleive he has the stuff to make at the ML level, a good #3 guy especially if you could slot him in between a couple of hard throwers.   Maybe I am being a little unkind to McCarver but there seems to be an anti-Yankee bias in a lot of commentators, not just him.  It also seems like his age is catching up with him.   It's nice to discuss this stuff from a point of winning instead of a point of desperation.  From my point of view, I'd really rather have our issues than say, the Sawx, who cannot keep a  decent SS since they let Garciaparra go and whose outfield looks a little suspect and a lot overpaid in right...plus Big Papi...now, there's a question mark if there ever was one.   Mike -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 8:36 am Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   I agree on letting Damon go.  And I think the reason they clicked, was that it simply got Derek out of the 2 hole.  He hits into too many DPs from there.  I think Johnny is replaceable.  Hideki reminds me more and more of Ruben Sierra, the mature Ruben.  A very dangerous hitter, and he has proven he can pinch hit.  So he doesn't have to play every day and that's great!   Right now I think you might be right.  We just don't have a ML catcher ready to go so it needs to be Molina for a year.  I like Cervelli's spirit, but it may have been his best year!   Hughes to the rotation and Joba to the pen, and don't forget CMW!  He may be available by early season, around May.  I'm not as high as you are on IPK.  Kennedy would have to do a great deal to earn a spot on my team, but if he can, so much the better.  I'd at least have him in spring training and give him the shot.   Andy/Randy?  I'd rather Andy, and I think he will come back for one more, and then I'm sure he's done.   Derek is not done until the end of the season and I've read where he would be willing to wait.  Pena can hit, so I think that is a no brainer.  He should be playiing somewhere in our infield, soon.  But one more year at short and then hopefully the OF for Derek.  I was kind of hoping that a win in the WS this year would make the transition palatable for Derek next season, but looking at it now, probably not.  Who knows?   Love your thoughts about McCarver, but I'd make sure he never got above AA ball.... On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 8:13 AM, <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote:   Scott, I agree 100%, plus during the playoffs he did not seem to have his head in the game at crucial times.  I also hate the way he spells his name, for what that's worth, LOL.   Here's my thinking on the upgrade issues:   1-Let Damon go.  There are enough good outfielders in market that you could even get a good cf and put him in left.  The big thing that concerns me about letting Damon go is his place in the lineup.  His hitting behind Jeter in the 2 hole was a terrific combination that clicked right off the bat.  This is really what we need by way of replacement, I believe.   2-Re-sign Matsui as the DH.  The guy is such a professional hitter and a clutch situational hitter...he would be very hard to replace.   3-Stick with the Posada/Molina duo for another year until a minor leaguer is ready to take over.  I really like Cervelli, to be honest with you but I wonder at this point if he will develop the pop in his bat.  Otherwise, I love the guy.   4-Put Hughes in the rotation and Joba in the pen.  The striking difference in Joba as a starter vs. reliever makes the decision almost a no-brainer.  The only blemish on him was leaving a ball inside to guy who kills that kind of pitch.  Hughes began to trust his stuff and that made all the difference in the world for him.  His trouble in the post-season was that he began to be concerned about the strengths and weaknesses of the hitter instead of pitching to his own strengths.  He has the moxy to be a good #3 or #4 guy right now and will with time move to a #2 or possibly #1 on the right team.   5-Sign Andy to a one year deal, if he wants to come back.  If he does want one more year, we're looking at CC, AJ, Andy, Phil and someone from the mix of Gaudin, Mitre, or Kennedy.  All 3 of the later options had their issues but I also believe they are all on target to correct the flaws.  I was especially impressed with Gaudin after he had worked out some kinks with the coaching staff.  Mitre has the kind of sinker that doesn't necessarily need 90+ to make a difference, he just has to be used regularly to keep his arm loose enough/tired enough to make the sinker work.  I also think Ian Kennedy has had enough humbling events to make him a valuable guy.  When he came up a couple years ago with a chip on his shoulder, it was a misplaced chip...his stuff did not back up his confidence.  I just think he's a different guy now from the inside out.   6-If Andy doesn't sign, I like Randy Wolf as cheap option.  I'd actually love us to sign John Lackey but I just can't see that happening, unless it looks as though the Sox might land him, LOL.   7-You gotta sign Derek for another 3 years at least.  Whether he can play SS for that time is another matter.  But here's another scenario:  Re-sign Derek but move him to left and either use Pena at short or go out and get a FA SS who can also bat at in the 2 hole.  Pena has the defense and showed signs of offensive capability so personally, I'd be okay with him at short.   8-We have the makings of a long term, absolutely terrific bullpen.  Roberston, Coke, Marte, Bruney (yes, Bruney), Aceves, and Mo.  I'll take that group right now against any other team in the world.  And this equation does not even contain Melancon, who I believe will be a very valuable piece as time moves forward.   9-Sign Tim McCarver to an exclusive YES network contract and then have him be the minor league broadcaster, as that seems where his talents seem most fitting.   Mike in Upstate NY, where we'll have temps in upper 60's with lots of sunshine today, the last hurrah before the long night of winter sets in...on the upside, I saw a nice 4 point buck on the way to church last night. -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter@ inbox.com> To: Yankeesmvp1 Group <yankeesmvp1@ yahoogroups. com> Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 7:18 am Subject: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   There seems to be one thread running through a lot of the articles I'm reading, and it has the Yankees picking up Figgins and putting him in LF.  Surely we have someone on the minor league staff somewhere as good or better than him?  He is a Yankees killer,, but he doesn't play that well against the other teams.  Plus I hate the way he spells his first name.  Just can't stand it. Light travels faster than sound. That is why some people appear bright until you hear them speak. Congratulations Yankees! Championship #27! Scott -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter ____________ _________ _________ _________ _________ __ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail. yahoo.com -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter

--
"You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle


Scott Coulter

 

I'm not saying Cervelli is mauer.  But, you never know what'll happen w/ Mauer.  He could get hurt.  He's a hometown boy who probably wants to stay w/ Mn and will give them a discount.  --- On Tue, 11/10/09, Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@...> wrote: From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@...> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@yahoogroups.com Date: Tuesday, November 10, 2009, 10:37 AM   hate to say it, but Cervelli is a good kid but he is not Joe Mauer. On Tue, Nov 10, 2009 at 10:30 AM, redbug <redbug51@yahoo. com> wrote:   Why not give Cervelli a shot while waiting to see if they want to take a shot at mauer? --- On Tue, 11/10/09, Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> wrote: From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Date: Tuesday, November 10, 2009, 6:57 AM   I just posted an article from the NYDN that makes this kind of speculation a moot point.  It details how weak this year's FA class is and how strong the one is for next year.  I think the Yankees might be best served to go with Johnny and Hideki for one more year, Jose as well, because there are guys the year after that where we will need to spend money.  Lackey might be the splash for this year because he is younger than Halladay next year we would have a shot at Joe Mauer plus a few other really good players.  I would even say fill the OF spot from within and suffer with Austin Jackson learning at the big league level if money is really an issue.  There are some good players coming up a year later. On Tue, Nov 10, 2009 at 6:15 AM, redbug <redbug51@yahoo. com> wrote:   I know he played 3rd but I can't remember his arm.  He hasn't played much outfield in recent yr's. Probably because they neeeded him at 3rd. --- On Mon, 11/9/09, Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> wrote: From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Date: Monday, November 9, 2009, 9:38 PM   I'm speaking strictly to his arm, nothing else.  He played 3rd base all season, probably one of the most demanding throwing positions on the field along with RF. On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 5:33 PM, redbug <redbug51@yahoo. com> wrote:   I'm about 5 emails behind you guys on Figgins but had one question...How's his arm?  Because it's hard to beat Johnny offensively and on the basepaths (I think his double steal was the Series).  Johnny's arm is his only majoe weakness.  If Figgins isn't a huge upgrade over Johnny in the field, why replace him? --- On Mon, 11/9/09, mikeman341@writeme. com <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote: From: mikeman341@writeme. com <mikeman341@writeme. com> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Date: Monday, November 9, 2009, 10:46 AM   Scott, You're right on both broadcasters.  Joe Morgan's 30+ years of defending his precious Reds as one of the best of all time is boring, misleading and incorrect.  Yes, they won back to back WS all those years ago, big deal.  In the ensuing time the Yanks have won er...let's see here I think the number is 7 WS titles, including 3 in a row and 4/5...but they'll never ever, ever be as good as the Reds.  Gimme a break.  I read somewhere that he is kind of hard to get along with in the prep and in the booth, I'm not surprised.   The Yanks have been preaching 'in house answers' since Cash got the promised control a few years ago.  I'd really like to see them give Pena a legit shot.  I had been eyeing JJ Hardy for a couple of years as a viable replacement for Jeter but he's off the market again.  I also like Tulo in Denver but I think he's signed long term.  I just really like the Pena option.  I'd like to see him get a real chance next year to win the job for himself.   I also like your assessment of Matsui and the comparison to Ruben Sierra.  Plus, Matsui really, really wants to come back to the Bronx.  I really like him as the DH for the next couple of years.   Mike -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 10:30 am Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   McCarver is a problem and so is Joe Morgan.  I wonder if it is because they were players and played against the Yankees for all those years?   I agree that Andy might take his glove and go home a winner, and he was one this year, that's for sure.   I'd like to see the Pena kid given a chance, I agee that as a SH he might do well for us in the 2 hole.  SH are very valuable, and I didn't notice that he had a weaker side.  He played a little OF towards the end of the season in Scranton, and that might not be a bad way to get up here.  I remember a young man named Mattingly who did it that way.  He turned out pretty good! On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 10:10 AM, <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote:   Scott, Yeah, I'd take Andy in a heartbeart over Randy.  I know Andy's family means a whole lot to him and missing his son's games is a tough one for him.  I am not at all sure he's coming back, in fact at this point, I think I'd be surprised a little bit if he does.  He wanted to pitch in the new stadium and help to bring another title here.  He accomplished what he wanted and would be leaving on an extremely high note.  I want him to come back, make no mistake about that.  I am convinced he has at least one more good season left in his arm and he could still be a terrific mentor for some of the young guys.   I like Pena at short and I can't help but wonder how he'd do in the 2 hole.  It would be a huge jump but he handles the bat well and he's a switch hitter.  I don't think we could expect much power but we have 6 other guys who supply that.  But for right now, Derek is the man at short.  Maybe he'll prove all the naysayers wrong two years running.  In the lineup, I wouldn't put him back at the 2 hole for the reason you mention...too many GIDP.   Kennedy is not flashing too bright on my radar but I do beleive he has the stuff to make at the ML level, a good #3 guy especially if you could slot him in between a couple of hard throwers.   Maybe I am being a little unkind to McCarver but there seems to be an anti-Yankee bias in a lot of commentators, not just him.  It also seems like his age is catching up with him.   It's nice to discuss this stuff from a point of winning instead of a point of desperation.  From my point of view, I'd really rather have our issues than say, the Sawx, who cannot keep a  decent SS since they let Garciaparra go and whose outfield looks a little suspect and a lot overpaid in right...plus Big Papi...now, there's a question mark if there ever was one.   Mike -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 8:36 am Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   I agree on letting Damon go.  And I think the reason they clicked, was that it simply got Derek out of the 2 hole.  He hits into too many DPs from there.  I think Johnny is replaceable.  Hideki reminds me more and more of Ruben Sierra, the mature Ruben.  A very dangerous hitter, and he has proven he can pinch hit.  So he doesn't have to play every day and that's great!   Right now I think you might be right.  We just don't have a ML catcher ready to go so it needs to be Molina for a year.  I like Cervelli's spirit, but it may have been his best year!   Hughes to the rotation and Joba to the pen, and don't forget CMW!  He may be available by early season, around May.  I'm not as high as you are on IPK.  Kennedy would have to do a great deal to earn a spot on my team, but if he can, so much the better.  I'd at least have him in spring training and give him the shot.   Andy/Randy?  I'd rather Andy, and I think he will come back for one more, and then I'm sure he's done.   Derek is not done until the end of the season and I've read where he would be willing to wait.  Pena can hit, so I think that is a no brainer.  He should be playiing somewhere in our infield, soon.  But one more year at short and then hopefully the OF for Derek.  I was kind of hoping that a win in the WS this year would make the transition palatable for Derek next season, but looking at it now, probably not.  Who knows?   Love your thoughts about McCarver, but I'd make sure he never got above AA ball.... On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 8:13 AM, <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote:   Scott, I agree 100%, plus during the playoffs he did not seem to have his head in the game at crucial times.  I also hate the way he spells his name, for what that's worth, LOL.   Here's my thinking on the upgrade issues:   1-Let Damon go.  There are enough good outfielders in market that you could even get a good cf and put him in left.  The big thing that concerns me about letting Damon go is his place in the lineup.  His hitting behind Jeter in the 2 hole was a terrific combination that clicked right off the bat.  This is really what we need by way of replacement, I believe.   2-Re-sign Matsui as the DH.  The guy is such a professional hitter and a clutch situational hitter...he would be very hard to replace.   3-Stick with the Posada/Molina duo for another year until a minor leaguer is ready to take over.  I really like Cervelli, to be honest with you but I wonder at this point if he will develop the pop in his bat.  Otherwise, I love the guy.   4-Put Hughes in the rotation and Joba in the pen.  The striking difference in Joba as a starter vs. reliever makes the decision almost a no-brainer.  The only blemish on him was leaving a ball inside to guy who kills that kind of pitch.  Hughes began to trust his stuff and that made all the difference in the world for him.  His trouble in the post-season was that he began to be concerned about the strengths and weaknesses of the hitter instead of pitching to his own strengths.  He has the moxy to be a good #3 or #4 guy right now and will with time move to a #2 or possibly #1 on the right team.   5-Sign Andy to a one year deal, if he wants to come back.  If he does want one more year, we're looking at CC, AJ, Andy, Phil and someone from the mix of Gaudin, Mitre, or Kennedy.  All 3 of the later options had their issues but I also believe they are all on target to correct the flaws.  I was especially impressed with Gaudin after he had worked out some kinks with the coaching staff.  Mitre has the kind of sinker that doesn't necessarily need 90+ to make a difference, he just has to be used regularly to keep his arm loose enough/tired enough to make the sinker work.  I also think Ian Kennedy has had enough humbling events to make him a valuable guy.  When he came up a couple years ago with a chip on his shoulder, it was a misplaced chip...his stuff did not back up his confidence.  I just think he's a different guy now from the inside out.   6-If Andy doesn't sign, I like Randy Wolf as cheap option.  I'd actually love us to sign John Lackey but I just can't see that happening, unless it looks as though the Sox might land him, LOL.   7-You gotta sign Derek for another 3 years at least.  Whether he can play SS for that time is another matter.  But here's another scenario:  Re-sign Derek but move him to left and either use Pena at short or go out and get a FA SS who can also bat at in the 2 hole.  Pena has the defense and showed signs of offensive capability so personally, I'd be okay with him at short.   8-We have the makings of a long term, absolutely terrific bullpen.  Roberston, Coke, Marte, Bruney (yes, Bruney), Aceves, and Mo.  I'll take that group right now against any other team in the world.  And this equation does not even contain Melancon, who I believe will be a very valuable piece as time moves forward.   9-Sign Tim McCarver to an exclusive YES network contract and then have him be the minor league broadcaster, as that seems where his talents seem most fitting.   Mike in Upstate NY, where we'll have temps in upper 60's with lots of sunshine today, the last hurrah before the long night of winter sets in...on the upside, I saw a nice 4 point buck on the way to church last night. -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter@ inbox.com> To: Yankeesmvp1 Group <yankeesmvp1@ yahoogroups. com> Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 7:18 am Subject: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   There seems to be one thread running through a lot of the articles I'm reading, and it has the Yankees picking up Figgins and putting him in LF.  Surely we have someone on the minor league staff somewhere as good or better than him?  He is a Yankees killer,, but he doesn't play that well against the other teams.  Plus I hate the way he spells his first name.  Just can't stand it. Light travels faster than sound. That is why some people appear bright until you hear them speak. Congratulations Yankees! Championship #27! Scott -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter ____________ _________ _________ _________ _________ __ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail. yahoo.com -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter

 

No catcher is Joe Mauer...Just wondering what they will do this one year before he is a FA. Remember though, he was born and raised in Minnesota and LOVEs it there from all reports. He may not want to leave, not even for the Yankees.

On Tue, Nov 10, 2009 at 10:37 AM, Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@...> wrote:

 

hate to say it, but Cervelli is a good kid but he is not Joe Mauer.

On Tue, Nov 10, 2009 at 10:30 AM, redbug <redbug51@...> wrote:

 

Why not give Cervelli a shot while waiting to see if they want to take a shot at mauer? --- On Tue, 11/10/09, Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@...> wrote: From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@...> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@yahoogroups.com Date: Tuesday, November 10, 2009, 6:57 AM   I just posted an article from the NYDN that makes this kind of speculation a moot point.  It details how weak this year's FA class is and how strong the one is for next year.  I think the Yankees might be best served to go with Johnny and Hideki for one more year, Jose as well, because there are guys the year after that where we will need to spend money.  Lackey might be the splash for this year because he is younger than Halladay next year we would have a shot at Joe Mauer plus a few other really good players.  I would even say fill the OF spot from within and suffer with Austin Jackson learning at the big league level if money is really an issue.  There are some good players coming up a year later. On Tue, Nov 10, 2009 at 6:15 AM, redbug <redbug51@yahoo. com> wrote:   I know he played 3rd but I can't remember his arm.  He hasn't played much outfield in recent yr's. Probably because they neeeded him at 3rd. --- On Mon, 11/9/09, Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> wrote: From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Date: Monday, November 9, 2009, 9:38 PM   I'm speaking strictly to his arm, nothing else.  He played 3rd base all season, probably one of the most demanding throwing positions on the field along with RF. On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 5:33 PM, redbug <redbug51@yahoo. com> wrote:   I'm about 5 emails behind you guys on Figgins but had one question...How's his arm?  Because it's hard to beat Johnny offensively and on the basepaths (I think his double steal was the Series).  Johnny's arm is his only majoe weakness.  If Figgins isn't a huge upgrade over Johnny in the field, why replace him? --- On Mon, 11/9/09, mikeman341@writeme. com <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote: From: mikeman341@writeme. com <mikeman341@writeme. com> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Date: Monday, November 9, 2009, 10:46 AM   Scott, You're right on both broadcasters.  Joe Morgan's 30+ years of defending his precious Reds as one of the best of all time is boring, misleading and incorrect.  Yes, they won back to back WS all those years ago, big deal.  In the ensuing time the Yanks have won er...let's see here I think the number is 7 WS titles, including 3 in a row and 4/5...but they'll never ever, ever be as good as the Reds.  Gimme a break.  I read somewhere that he is kind of hard to get along with in the prep and in the booth, I'm not surprised.   The Yanks have been preaching 'in house answers' since Cash got the promised control a few years ago.  I'd really like to see them give Pena a legit shot.  I had been eyeing JJ Hardy for a couple of years as a viable replacement for Jeter but he's off the market again.  I also like Tulo in Denver but I think he's signed long term.  I just really like the Pena option.  I'd like to see him get a real chance next year to win the job for himself.   I also like your assessment of Matsui and the comparison to Ruben Sierra.  Plus, Matsui really, really wants to come back to the Bronx.  I really like him as the DH for the next couple of years.   Mike -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 10:30 am Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   McCarver is a problem and so is Joe Morgan.  I wonder if it is because they were players and played against the Yankees for all those years?   I agree that Andy might take his glove and go home a winner, and he was one this year, that's for sure.   I'd like to see the Pena kid given a chance, I agee that as a SH he might do well for us in the 2 hole.  SH are very valuable, and I didn't notice that he had a weaker side.  He played a little OF towards the end of the season in Scranton, and that might not be a bad way to get up here.  I remember a young man named Mattingly who did it that way.  He turned out pretty good! On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 10:10 AM, <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote:   Scott, Yeah, I'd take Andy in a heartbeart over Randy.  I know Andy's family means a whole lot to him and missing his son's games is a tough one for him.  I am not at all sure he's coming back, in fact at this point, I think I'd be surprised a little bit if he does.  He wanted to pitch in the new stadium and help to bring another title here.  He accomplished what he wanted and would be leaving on an extremely high note.  I want him to come back, make no mistake about that.  I am convinced he has at least one more good season left in his arm and he could still be a terrific mentor for some of the young guys.   I like Pena at short and I can't help but wonder how he'd do in the 2 hole.  It would be a huge jump but he handles the bat well and he's a switch hitter.  I don't think we could expect much power but we have 6 other guys who supply that.  But for right now, Derek is the man at short.  Maybe he'll prove all the naysayers wrong two years running.  In the lineup, I wouldn't put him back at the 2 hole for the reason you mention...too many GIDP.   Kennedy is not flashing too bright on my radar but I do beleive he has the stuff to make at the ML level, a good #3 guy especially if you could slot him in between a couple of hard throwers.   Maybe I am being a little unkind to McCarver but there seems to be an anti-Yankee bias in a lot of commentators, not just him.  It also seems like his age is catching up with him.   It's nice to discuss this stuff from a point of winning instead of a point of desperation.  From my point of view, I'd really rather have our issues than say, the Sawx, who cannot keep a  decent SS since they let Garciaparra go and whose outfield looks a little suspect and a lot overpaid in right...plus Big Papi...now, there's a question mark if there ever was one.   Mike -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 8:36 am Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   I agree on letting Damon go.  And I think the reason they clicked, was that it simply got Derek out of the 2 hole.  He hits into too many DPs from there.  I think Johnny is replaceable.  Hideki reminds me more and more of Ruben Sierra, the mature Ruben.  A very dangerous hitter, and he has proven he can pinch hit.  So he doesn't have to play every day and that's great!   Right now I think you might be right.  We just don't have a ML catcher ready to go so it needs to be Molina for a year.  I like Cervelli's spirit, but it may have been his best year!   Hughes to the rotation and Joba to the pen, and don't forget CMW!  He may be available by early season, around May.  I'm not as high as you are on IPK.  Kennedy would have to do a great deal to earn a spot on my team, but if he can, so much the better.  I'd at least have him in spring training and give him the shot.   Andy/Randy?  I'd rather Andy, and I think he will come back for one more, and then I'm sure he's done.   Derek is not done until the end of the season and I've read where he would be willing to wait.  Pena can hit, so I think that is a no brainer.  He should be playiing somewhere in our infield, soon.  But one more year at short and then hopefully the OF for Derek.  I was kind of hoping that a win in the WS this year would make the transition palatable for Derek next season, but looking at it now, probably not.  Who knows?   Love your thoughts about McCarver, but I'd make sure he never got above AA ball.... On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 8:13 AM, <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote:   Scott, I agree 100%, plus during the playoffs he did not seem to have his head in the game at crucial times.  I also hate the way he spells his name, for what that's worth, LOL.   Here's my thinking on the upgrade issues:   1-Let Damon go.  There are enough good outfielders in market that you could even get a good cf and put him in left.  The big thing that concerns me about letting Damon go is his place in the lineup.  His hitting behind Jeter in the 2 hole was a terrific combination that clicked right off the bat.  This is really what we need by way of replacement, I believe.   2-Re-sign Matsui as the DH.  The guy is such a professional hitter and a clutch situational hitter...he would be very hard to replace.   3-Stick with the Posada/Molina duo for another year until a minor leaguer is ready to take over.  I really like Cervelli, to be honest with you but I wonder at this point if he will develop the pop in his bat.  Otherwise, I love the guy.   4-Put Hughes in the rotation and Joba in the pen.  The striking difference in Joba as a starter vs. reliever makes the decision almost a no-brainer.  The only blemish on him was leaving a ball inside to guy who kills that kind of pitch.  Hughes began to trust his stuff and that made all the difference in the world for him.  His trouble in the post-season was that he began to be concerned about the strengths and weaknesses of the hitter instead of pitching to his own strengths.  He has the moxy to be a good #3 or #4 guy right now and will with time move to a #2 or possibly #1 on the right team.   5-Sign Andy to a one year deal, if he wants to come back.  If he does want one more year, we're looking at CC, AJ, Andy, Phil and someone from the mix of Gaudin, Mitre, or Kennedy.  All 3 of the later options had their issues but I also believe they are all on target to correct the flaws.  I was especially impressed with Gaudin after he had worked out some kinks with the coaching staff.  Mitre has the kind of sinker that doesn't necessarily need 90+ to make a difference, he just has to be used regularly to keep his arm loose enough/tired enough to make the sinker work.  I also think Ian Kennedy has had enough humbling events to make him a valuable guy.  When he came up a couple years ago with a chip on his shoulder, it was a misplaced chip...his stuff did not back up his confidence.  I just think he's a different guy now from the inside out.   6-If Andy doesn't sign, I like Randy Wolf as cheap option.  I'd actually love us to sign John Lackey but I just can't see that happening, unless it looks as though the Sox might land him, LOL.   7-You gotta sign Derek for another 3 years at least.  Whether he can play SS for that time is another matter.  But here's another scenario:  Re-sign Derek but move him to left and either use Pena at short or go out and get a FA SS who can also bat at in the 2 hole.  Pena has the defense and showed signs of offensive capability so personally, I'd be okay with him at short.   8-We have the makings of a long term, absolutely terrific bullpen.  Roberston, Coke, Marte, Bruney (yes, Bruney), Aceves, and Mo.  I'll take that group right now against any other team in the world.  And this equation does not even contain Melancon, who I believe will be a very valuable piece as time moves forward.   9-Sign Tim McCarver to an exclusive YES network contract and then have him be the minor league broadcaster, as that seems where his talents seem most fitting.   Mike in Upstate NY, where we'll have temps in upper 60's with lots of sunshine today, the last hurrah before the long night of winter sets in...on the upside, I saw a nice 4 point buck on the way to church last night. -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter@ inbox.com> To: Yankeesmvp1 Group <yankeesmvp1@ yahoogroups. com> Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 7:18 am Subject: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   There seems to be one thread running through a lot of the articles I'm reading, and it has the Yankees picking up Figgins and putting him in LF.  Surely we have someone on the minor league staff somewhere as good or better than him?  He is a Yankees killer,, but he doesn't play that well against the other teams.  Plus I hate the way he spells his first name.  Just can't stand it. Light travels faster than sound. That is why some people appear bright until you hear them speak. Congratulations Yankees! Championship #27! Scott -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter ____________ _________ _________ _________ _________ __ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail. yahoo.com -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter

--
"You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle


Scott Coulter

--

Imagine Peace

 

hate to say it, but Cervelli is a good kid but he is not Joe Mauer.

On Tue, Nov 10, 2009 at 10:30 AM, redbug <redbug51@...> wrote:

 

Why not give Cervelli a shot while waiting to see if they want to take a shot at mauer? --- On Tue, 11/10/09, Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@...> wrote: From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@...> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@yahoogroups.com Date: Tuesday, November 10, 2009, 6:57 AM   I just posted an article from the NYDN that makes this kind of speculation a moot point.  It details how weak this year's FA class is and how strong the one is for next year.  I think the Yankees might be best served to go with Johnny and Hideki for one more year, Jose as well, because there are guys the year after that where we will need to spend money.  Lackey might be the splash for this year because he is younger than Halladay next year we would have a shot at Joe Mauer plus a few other really good players.  I would even say fill the OF spot from within and suffer with Austin Jackson learning at the big league level if money is really an issue.  There are some good players coming up a year later. On Tue, Nov 10, 2009 at 6:15 AM, redbug <redbug51@yahoo. com> wrote:   I know he played 3rd but I can't remember his arm.  He hasn't played much outfield in recent yr's. Probably because they neeeded him at 3rd. --- On Mon, 11/9/09, Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> wrote: From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Date: Monday, November 9, 2009, 9:38 PM   I'm speaking strictly to his arm, nothing else.  He played 3rd base all season, probably one of the most demanding throwing positions on the field along with RF. On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 5:33 PM, redbug <redbug51@yahoo. com> wrote:   I'm about 5 emails behind you guys on Figgins but had one question...How's his arm?  Because it's hard to beat Johnny offensively and on the basepaths (I think his double steal was the Series).  Johnny's arm is his only majoe weakness.  If Figgins isn't a huge upgrade over Johnny in the field, why replace him? --- On Mon, 11/9/09, mikeman341@writeme. com <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote: From: mikeman341@writeme. com <mikeman341@writeme. com> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Date: Monday, November 9, 2009, 10:46 AM   Scott, You're right on both broadcasters.  Joe Morgan's 30+ years of defending his precious Reds as one of the best of all time is boring, misleading and incorrect.  Yes, they won back to back WS all those years ago, big deal.  In the ensuing time the Yanks have won er...let's see here I think the number is 7 WS titles, including 3 in a row and 4/5...but they'll never ever, ever be as good as the Reds.  Gimme a break.  I read somewhere that he is kind of hard to get along with in the prep and in the booth, I'm not surprised.   The Yanks have been preaching 'in house answers' since Cash got the promised control a few years ago.  I'd really like to see them give Pena a legit shot.  I had been eyeing JJ Hardy for a couple of years as a viable replacement for Jeter but he's off the market again.  I also like Tulo in Denver but I think he's signed long term.  I just really like the Pena option.  I'd like to see him get a real chance next year to win the job for himself.   I also like your assessment of Matsui and the comparison to Ruben Sierra.  Plus, Matsui really, really wants to come back to the Bronx.  I really like him as the DH for the next couple of years.   Mike -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 10:30 am Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   McCarver is a problem and so is Joe Morgan.  I wonder if it is because they were players and played against the Yankees for all those years?   I agree that Andy might take his glove and go home a winner, and he was one this year, that's for sure.   I'd like to see the Pena kid given a chance, I agee that as a SH he might do well for us in the 2 hole.  SH are very valuable, and I didn't notice that he had a weaker side.  He played a little OF towards the end of the season in Scranton, and that might not be a bad way to get up here.  I remember a young man named Mattingly who did it that way.  He turned out pretty good! On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 10:10 AM, <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote:   Scott, Yeah, I'd take Andy in a heartbeart over Randy.  I know Andy's family means a whole lot to him and missing his son's games is a tough one for him.  I am not at all sure he's coming back, in fact at this point, I think I'd be surprised a little bit if he does.  He wanted to pitch in the new stadium and help to bring another title here.  He accomplished what he wanted and would be leaving on an extremely high note.  I want him to come back, make no mistake about that.  I am convinced he has at least one more good season left in his arm and he could still be a terrific mentor for some of the young guys.   I like Pena at short and I can't help but wonder how he'd do in the 2 hole.  It would be a huge jump but he handles the bat well and he's a switch hitter.  I don't think we could expect much power but we have 6 other guys who supply that.  But for right now, Derek is the man at short.  Maybe he'll prove all the naysayers wrong two years running.  In the lineup, I wouldn't put him back at the 2 hole for the reason you mention...too many GIDP.   Kennedy is not flashing too bright on my radar but I do beleive he has the stuff to make at the ML level, a good #3 guy especially if you could slot him in between a couple of hard throwers.   Maybe I am being a little unkind to McCarver but there seems to be an anti-Yankee bias in a lot of commentators, not just him.  It also seems like his age is catching up with him.   It's nice to discuss this stuff from a point of winning instead of a point of desperation.  From my point of view, I'd really rather have our issues than say, the Sawx, who cannot keep a  decent SS since they let Garciaparra go and whose outfield looks a little suspect and a lot overpaid in right...plus Big Papi...now, there's a question mark if there ever was one.   Mike -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 8:36 am Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   I agree on letting Damon go.  And I think the reason they clicked, was that it simply got Derek out of the 2 hole.  He hits into too many DPs from there.  I think Johnny is replaceable.  Hideki reminds me more and more of Ruben Sierra, the mature Ruben.  A very dangerous hitter, and he has proven he can pinch hit.  So he doesn't have to play every day and that's great!   Right now I think you might be right.  We just don't have a ML catcher ready to go so it needs to be Molina for a year.  I like Cervelli's spirit, but it may have been his best year!   Hughes to the rotation and Joba to the pen, and don't forget CMW!  He may be available by early season, around May.  I'm not as high as you are on IPK.  Kennedy would have to do a great deal to earn a spot on my team, but if he can, so much the better.  I'd at least have him in spring training and give him the shot.   Andy/Randy?  I'd rather Andy, and I think he will come back for one more, and then I'm sure he's done.   Derek is not done until the end of the season and I've read where he would be willing to wait.  Pena can hit, so I think that is a no brainer.  He should be playiing somewhere in our infield, soon.  But one more year at short and then hopefully the OF for Derek.  I was kind of hoping that a win in the WS this year would make the transition palatable for Derek next season, but looking at it now, probably not.  Who knows?   Love your thoughts about McCarver, but I'd make sure he never got above AA ball.... On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 8:13 AM, <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote:   Scott, I agree 100%, plus during the playoffs he did not seem to have his head in the game at crucial times.  I also hate the way he spells his name, for what that's worth, LOL.   Here's my thinking on the upgrade issues:   1-Let Damon go.  There are enough good outfielders in market that you could even get a good cf and put him in left.  The big thing that concerns me about letting Damon go is his place in the lineup.  His hitting behind Jeter in the 2 hole was a terrific combination that clicked right off the bat.  This is really what we need by way of replacement, I believe.   2-Re-sign Matsui as the DH.  The guy is such a professional hitter and a clutch situational hitter...he would be very hard to replace.   3-Stick with the Posada/Molina duo for another year until a minor leaguer is ready to take over.  I really like Cervelli, to be honest with you but I wonder at this point if he will develop the pop in his bat.  Otherwise, I love the guy.   4-Put Hughes in the rotation and Joba in the pen.  The striking difference in Joba as a starter vs. reliever makes the decision almost a no-brainer.  The only blemish on him was leaving a ball inside to guy who kills that kind of pitch.  Hughes began to trust his stuff and that made all the difference in the world for him.  His trouble in the post-season was that he began to be concerned about the strengths and weaknesses of the hitter instead of pitching to his own strengths.  He has the moxy to be a good #3 or #4 guy right now and will with time move to a #2 or possibly #1 on the right team.   5-Sign Andy to a one year deal, if he wants to come back.  If he does want one more year, we're looking at CC, AJ, Andy, Phil and someone from the mix of Gaudin, Mitre, or Kennedy.  All 3 of the later options had their issues but I also believe they are all on target to correct the flaws.  I was especially impressed with Gaudin after he had worked out some kinks with the coaching staff.  Mitre has the kind of sinker that doesn't necessarily need 90+ to make a difference, he just has to be used regularly to keep his arm loose enough/tired enough to make the sinker work.  I also think Ian Kennedy has had enough humbling events to make him a valuable guy.  When he came up a couple years ago with a chip on his shoulder, it was a misplaced chip...his stuff did not back up his confidence.  I just think he's a different guy now from the inside out.   6-If Andy doesn't sign, I like Randy Wolf as cheap option.  I'd actually love us to sign John Lackey but I just can't see that happening, unless it looks as though the Sox might land him, LOL.   7-You gotta sign Derek for another 3 years at least.  Whether he can play SS for that time is another matter.  But here's another scenario:  Re-sign Derek but move him to left and either use Pena at short or go out and get a FA SS who can also bat at in the 2 hole.  Pena has the defense and showed signs of offensive capability so personally, I'd be okay with him at short.   8-We have the makings of a long term, absolutely terrific bullpen.  Roberston, Coke, Marte, Bruney (yes, Bruney), Aceves, and Mo.  I'll take that group right now against any other team in the world.  And this equation does not even contain Melancon, who I believe will be a very valuable piece as time moves forward.   9-Sign Tim McCarver to an exclusive YES network contract and then have him be the minor league broadcaster, as that seems where his talents seem most fitting.   Mike in Upstate NY, where we'll have temps in upper 60's with lots of sunshine today, the last hurrah before the long night of winter sets in...on the upside, I saw a nice 4 point buck on the way to church last night. -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter@ inbox.com> To: Yankeesmvp1 Group <yankeesmvp1@ yahoogroups. com> Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 7:18 am Subject: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   There seems to be one thread running through a lot of the articles I'm reading, and it has the Yankees picking up Figgins and putting him in LF.  Surely we have someone on the minor league staff somewhere as good or better than him?  He is a Yankees killer,, but he doesn't play that well against the other teams.  Plus I hate the way he spells his first name.  Just can't stand it. Light travels faster than sound. That is why some people appear bright until you hear them speak. Congratulations Yankees! Championship #27! Scott -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter ____________ _________ _________ _________ _________ __ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail. yahoo.com -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter

--
"You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle


Scott Coulter

 

Why not give Cervelli a shot while waiting to see if they want to take a shot at mauer? --- On Tue, 11/10/09, Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@...> wrote: From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@...> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@yahoogroups.com Date: Tuesday, November 10, 2009, 6:57 AM   I just posted an article from the NYDN that makes this kind of speculation a moot point.  It details how weak this year's FA class is and how strong the one is for next year.  I think the Yankees might be best served to go with Johnny and Hideki for one more year, Jose as well, because there are guys the year after that where we will need to spend money.  Lackey might be the splash for this year because he is younger than Halladay next year we would have a shot at Joe Mauer plus a few other really good players.  I would even say fill the OF spot from within and suffer with Austin Jackson learning at the big league level if money is really an issue.  There are some good players coming up a year later. On Tue, Nov 10, 2009 at 6:15 AM, redbug <redbug51@yahoo. com> wrote:   I know he played 3rd but I can't remember his arm.  He hasn't played much outfield in recent yr's. Probably because they neeeded him at 3rd. --- On Mon, 11/9/09, Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> wrote: From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Date: Monday, November 9, 2009, 9:38 PM   I'm speaking strictly to his arm, nothing else.  He played 3rd base all season, probably one of the most demanding throwing positions on the field along with RF. On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 5:33 PM, redbug <redbug51@yahoo. com> wrote:   I'm about 5 emails behind you guys on Figgins but had one question...How's his arm?  Because it's hard to beat Johnny offensively and on the basepaths (I think his double steal was the Series).  Johnny's arm is his only majoe weakness.  If Figgins isn't a huge upgrade over Johnny in the field, why replace him? --- On Mon, 11/9/09, mikeman341@writeme. com <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote: From: mikeman341@writeme. com <mikeman341@writeme. com> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Date: Monday, November 9, 2009, 10:46 AM   Scott, You're right on both broadcasters.  Joe Morgan's 30+ years of defending his precious Reds as one of the best of all time is boring, misleading and incorrect.  Yes, they won back to back WS all those years ago, big deal.  In the ensuing time the Yanks have won er...let's see here I think the number is 7 WS titles, including 3 in a row and 4/5...but they'll never ever, ever be as good as the Reds.  Gimme a break.  I read somewhere that he is kind of hard to get along with in the prep and in the booth, I'm not surprised.   The Yanks have been preaching 'in house answers' since Cash got the promised control a few years ago.  I'd really like to see them give Pena a legit shot.  I had been eyeing JJ Hardy for a couple of years as a viable replacement for Jeter but he's off the market again.  I also like Tulo in Denver but I think he's signed long term.  I just really like the Pena option.  I'd like to see him get a real chance next year to win the job for himself.   I also like your assessment of Matsui and the comparison to Ruben Sierra.  Plus, Matsui really, really wants to come back to the Bronx.  I really like him as the DH for the next couple of years.   Mike -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 10:30 am Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   McCarver is a problem and so is Joe Morgan.  I wonder if it is because they were players and played against the Yankees for all those years?   I agree that Andy might take his glove and go home a winner, and he was one this year, that's for sure.   I'd like to see the Pena kid given a chance, I agee that as a SH he might do well for us in the 2 hole.  SH are very valuable, and I didn't notice that he had a weaker side.  He played a little OF towards the end of the season in Scranton, and that might not be a bad way to get up here.  I remember a young man named Mattingly who did it that way.  He turned out pretty good! On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 10:10 AM, <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote:   Scott, Yeah, I'd take Andy in a heartbeart over Randy.  I know Andy's family means a whole lot to him and missing his son's games is a tough one for him.  I am not at all sure he's coming back, in fact at this point, I think I'd be surprised a little bit if he does.  He wanted to pitch in the new stadium and help to bring another title here.  He accomplished what he wanted and would be leaving on an extremely high note.  I want him to come back, make no mistake about that.  I am convinced he has at least one more good season left in his arm and he could still be a terrific mentor for some of the young guys.   I like Pena at short and I can't help but wonder how he'd do in the 2 hole.  It would be a huge jump but he handles the bat well and he's a switch hitter.  I don't think we could expect much power but we have 6 other guys who supply that.  But for right now, Derek is the man at short.  Maybe he'll prove all the naysayers wrong two years running.  In the lineup, I wouldn't put him back at the 2 hole for the reason you mention...too many GIDP.   Kennedy is not flashing too bright on my radar but I do beleive he has the stuff to make at the ML level, a good #3 guy especially if you could slot him in between a couple of hard throwers.   Maybe I am being a little unkind to McCarver but there seems to be an anti-Yankee bias in a lot of commentators, not just him.  It also seems like his age is catching up with him.   It's nice to discuss this stuff from a point of winning instead of a point of desperation.  From my point of view, I'd really rather have our issues than say, the Sawx, who cannot keep a  decent SS since they let Garciaparra go and whose outfield looks a little suspect and a lot overpaid in right...plus Big Papi...now, there's a question mark if there ever was one.   Mike -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 8:36 am Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   I agree on letting Damon go.  And I think the reason they clicked, was that it simply got Derek out of the 2 hole.  He hits into too many DPs from there.  I think Johnny is replaceable.  Hideki reminds me more and more of Ruben Sierra, the mature Ruben.  A very dangerous hitter, and he has proven he can pinch hit.  So he doesn't have to play every day and that's great!   Right now I think you might be right.  We just don't have a ML catcher ready to go so it needs to be Molina for a year.  I like Cervelli's spirit, but it may have been his best year!   Hughes to the rotation and Joba to the pen, and don't forget CMW!  He may be available by early season, around May.  I'm not as high as you are on IPK.  Kennedy would have to do a great deal to earn a spot on my team, but if he can, so much the better.  I'd at least have him in spring training and give him the shot.   Andy/Randy?  I'd rather Andy, and I think he will come back for one more, and then I'm sure he's done.   Derek is not done until the end of the season and I've read where he would be willing to wait.  Pena can hit, so I think that is a no brainer.  He should be playiing somewhere in our infield, soon.  But one more year at short and then hopefully the OF for Derek.  I was kind of hoping that a win in the WS this year would make the transition palatable for Derek next season, but looking at it now, probably not.  Who knows?   Love your thoughts about McCarver, but I'd make sure he never got above AA ball.... On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 8:13 AM, <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote:   Scott, I agree 100%, plus during the playoffs he did not seem to have his head in the game at crucial times.  I also hate the way he spells his name, for what that's worth, LOL.   Here's my thinking on the upgrade issues:   1-Let Damon go.  There are enough good outfielders in market that you could even get a good cf and put him in left.  The big thing that concerns me about letting Damon go is his place in the lineup.  His hitting behind Jeter in the 2 hole was a terrific combination that clicked right off the bat.  This is really what we need by way of replacement, I believe.   2-Re-sign Matsui as the DH.  The guy is such a professional hitter and a clutch situational hitter...he would be very hard to replace.   3-Stick with the Posada/Molina duo for another year until a minor leaguer is ready to take over.  I really like Cervelli, to be honest with you but I wonder at this point if he will develop the pop in his bat.  Otherwise, I love the guy.   4-Put Hughes in the rotation and Joba in the pen.  The striking difference in Joba as a starter vs. reliever makes the decision almost a no-brainer.  The only blemish on him was leaving a ball inside to guy who kills that kind of pitch.  Hughes began to trust his stuff and that made all the difference in the world for him.  His trouble in the post-season was that he began to be concerned about the strengths and weaknesses of the hitter instead of pitching to his own strengths.  He has the moxy to be a good #3 or #4 guy right now and will with time move to a #2 or possibly #1 on the right team.   5-Sign Andy to a one year deal, if he wants to come back.  If he does want one more year, we're looking at CC, AJ, Andy, Phil and someone from the mix of Gaudin, Mitre, or Kennedy.  All 3 of the later options had their issues but I also believe they are all on target to correct the flaws.  I was especially impressed with Gaudin after he had worked out some kinks with the coaching staff.  Mitre has the kind of sinker that doesn't necessarily need 90+ to make a difference, he just has to be used regularly to keep his arm loose enough/tired enough to make the sinker work.  I also think Ian Kennedy has had enough humbling events to make him a valuable guy.  When he came up a couple years ago with a chip on his shoulder, it was a misplaced chip...his stuff did not back up his confidence.  I just think he's a different guy now from the inside out.   6-If Andy doesn't sign, I like Randy Wolf as cheap option.  I'd actually love us to sign John Lackey but I just can't see that happening, unless it looks as though the Sox might land him, LOL.   7-You gotta sign Derek for another 3 years at least.  Whether he can play SS for that time is another matter.  But here's another scenario:  Re-sign Derek but move him to left and either use Pena at short or go out and get a FA SS who can also bat at in the 2 hole.  Pena has the defense and showed signs of offensive capability so personally, I'd be okay with him at short.   8-We have the makings of a long term, absolutely terrific bullpen.  Roberston, Coke, Marte, Bruney (yes, Bruney), Aceves, and Mo.  I'll take that group right now against any other team in the world.  And this equation does not even contain Melancon, who I believe will be a very valuable piece as time moves forward.   9-Sign Tim McCarver to an exclusive YES network contract and then have him be the minor league broadcaster, as that seems where his talents seem most fitting.   Mike in Upstate NY, where we'll have temps in upper 60's with lots of sunshine today, the last hurrah before the long night of winter sets in...on the upside, I saw a nice 4 point buck on the way to church last night. -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter@ inbox.com> To: Yankeesmvp1 Group <yankeesmvp1@ yahoogroups. com> Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 7:18 am Subject: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   There seems to be one thread running through a lot of the articles I'm reading, and it has the Yankees picking up Figgins and putting him in LF.  Surely we have someone on the minor league staff somewhere as good or better than him?  He is a Yankees killer,, but he doesn't play that well against the other teams.  Plus I hate the way he spells his first name.  Just can't stand it. Light travels faster than sound. That is why some people appear bright until you hear them speak. Congratulations Yankees! Championship #27! Scott -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter ____________ _________ _________ _________ _________ __ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail. yahoo.com -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter

 

Why not give Cervelli a shot while waiting to see if they want to take a shot at mauer? --- On Tue, 11/10/09, Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@...> wrote: From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@...> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@yahoogroups.com Date: Tuesday, November 10, 2009, 6:57 AM   I just posted an article from the NYDN that makes this kind of speculation a moot point.  It details how weak this year's FA class is and how strong the one is for next year.  I think the Yankees might be best served to go with Johnny and Hideki for one more year, Jose as well, because there are guys the year after that where we will need to spend money.  Lackey might be the splash for this year because he is younger than Halladay next year we would have a shot at Joe Mauer plus a few other really good players.  I would even say fill the OF spot from within and suffer with Austin Jackson learning at the big league level if money is really an issue.  There are some good players coming up a year later. On Tue, Nov 10, 2009 at 6:15 AM, redbug <redbug51@yahoo. com> wrote:   I know he played 3rd but I can't remember his arm.  He hasn't played much outfield in recent yr's. Probably because they neeeded him at 3rd. --- On Mon, 11/9/09, Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> wrote: From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Date: Monday, November 9, 2009, 9:38 PM   I'm speaking strictly to his arm, nothing else.  He played 3rd base all season, probably one of the most demanding throwing positions on the field along with RF. On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 5:33 PM, redbug <redbug51@yahoo. com> wrote:   I'm about 5 emails behind you guys on Figgins but had one question...How's his arm?  Because it's hard to beat Johnny offensively and on the basepaths (I think his double steal was the Series).  Johnny's arm is his only majoe weakness.  If Figgins isn't a huge upgrade over Johnny in the field, why replace him? --- On Mon, 11/9/09, mikeman341@writeme. com <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote: From: mikeman341@writeme. com <mikeman341@writeme. com> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Date: Monday, November 9, 2009, 10:46 AM   Scott, You're right on both broadcasters.  Joe Morgan's 30+ years of defending his precious Reds as one of the best of all time is boring, misleading and incorrect.  Yes, they won back to back WS all those years ago, big deal.  In the ensuing time the Yanks have won er...let's see here I think the number is 7 WS titles, including 3 in a row and 4/5...but they'll never ever, ever be as good as the Reds.  Gimme a break.  I read somewhere that he is kind of hard to get along with in the prep and in the booth, I'm not surprised.   The Yanks have been preaching 'in house answers' since Cash got the promised control a few years ago.  I'd really like to see them give Pena a legit shot.  I had been eyeing JJ Hardy for a couple of years as a viable replacement for Jeter but he's off the market again.  I also like Tulo in Denver but I think he's signed long term.  I just really like the Pena option.  I'd like to see him get a real chance next year to win the job for himself.   I also like your assessment of Matsui and the comparison to Ruben Sierra.  Plus, Matsui really, really wants to come back to the Bronx.  I really like him as the DH for the next couple of years.   Mike -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 10:30 am Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   McCarver is a problem and so is Joe Morgan.  I wonder if it is because they were players and played against the Yankees for all those years?   I agree that Andy might take his glove and go home a winner, and he was one this year, that's for sure.   I'd like to see the Pena kid given a chance, I agee that as a SH he might do well for us in the 2 hole.  SH are very valuable, and I didn't notice that he had a weaker side.  He played a little OF towards the end of the season in Scranton, and that might not be a bad way to get up here.  I remember a young man named Mattingly who did it that way.  He turned out pretty good! On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 10:10 AM, <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote:   Scott, Yeah, I'd take Andy in a heartbeart over Randy.  I know Andy's family means a whole lot to him and missing his son's games is a tough one for him.  I am not at all sure he's coming back, in fact at this point, I think I'd be surprised a little bit if he does.  He wanted to pitch in the new stadium and help to bring another title here.  He accomplished what he wanted and would be leaving on an extremely high note.  I want him to come back, make no mistake about that.  I am convinced he has at least one more good season left in his arm and he could still be a terrific mentor for some of the young guys.   I like Pena at short and I can't help but wonder how he'd do in the 2 hole.  It would be a huge jump but he handles the bat well and he's a switch hitter.  I don't think we could expect much power but we have 6 other guys who supply that.  But for right now, Derek is the man at short.  Maybe he'll prove all the naysayers wrong two years running.  In the lineup, I wouldn't put him back at the 2 hole for the reason you mention...too many GIDP.   Kennedy is not flashing too bright on my radar but I do beleive he has the stuff to make at the ML level, a good #3 guy especially if you could slot him in between a couple of hard throwers.   Maybe I am being a little unkind to McCarver but there seems to be an anti-Yankee bias in a lot of commentators, not just him.  It also seems like his age is catching up with him.   It's nice to discuss this stuff from a point of winning instead of a point of desperation.  From my point of view, I'd really rather have our issues than say, the Sawx, who cannot keep a  decent SS since they let Garciaparra go and whose outfield looks a little suspect and a lot overpaid in right...plus Big Papi...now, there's a question mark if there ever was one.   Mike -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 8:36 am Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   I agree on letting Damon go.  And I think the reason they clicked, was that it simply got Derek out of the 2 hole.  He hits into too many DPs from there.  I think Johnny is replaceable.  Hideki reminds me more and more of Ruben Sierra, the mature Ruben.  A very dangerous hitter, and he has proven he can pinch hit.  So he doesn't have to play every day and that's great!   Right now I think you might be right.  We just don't have a ML catcher ready to go so it needs to be Molina for a year.  I like Cervelli's spirit, but it may have been his best year!   Hughes to the rotation and Joba to the pen, and don't forget CMW!  He may be available by early season, around May.  I'm not as high as you are on IPK.  Kennedy would have to do a great deal to earn a spot on my team, but if he can, so much the better.  I'd at least have him in spring training and give him the shot.   Andy/Randy?  I'd rather Andy, and I think he will come back for one more, and then I'm sure he's done.   Derek is not done until the end of the season and I've read where he would be willing to wait.  Pena can hit, so I think that is a no brainer.  He should be playiing somewhere in our infield, soon.  But one more year at short and then hopefully the OF for Derek.  I was kind of hoping that a win in the WS this year would make the transition palatable for Derek next season, but looking at it now, probably not.  Who knows?   Love your thoughts about McCarver, but I'd make sure he never got above AA ball.... On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 8:13 AM, <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote:   Scott, I agree 100%, plus during the playoffs he did not seem to have his head in the game at crucial times.  I also hate the way he spells his name, for what that's worth, LOL.   Here's my thinking on the upgrade issues:   1-Let Damon go.  There are enough good outfielders in market that you could even get a good cf and put him in left.  The big thing that concerns me about letting Damon go is his place in the lineup.  His hitting behind Jeter in the 2 hole was a terrific combination that clicked right off the bat.  This is really what we need by way of replacement, I believe.   2-Re-sign Matsui as the DH.  The guy is such a professional hitter and a clutch situational hitter...he would be very hard to replace.   3-Stick with the Posada/Molina duo for another year until a minor leaguer is ready to take over.  I really like Cervelli, to be honest with you but I wonder at this point if he will develop the pop in his bat.  Otherwise, I love the guy.   4-Put Hughes in the rotation and Joba in the pen.  The striking difference in Joba as a starter vs. reliever makes the decision almost a no-brainer.  The only blemish on him was leaving a ball inside to guy who kills that kind of pitch.  Hughes began to trust his stuff and that made all the difference in the world for him.  His trouble in the post-season was that he began to be concerned about the strengths and weaknesses of the hitter instead of pitching to his own strengths.  He has the moxy to be a good #3 or #4 guy right now and will with time move to a #2 or possibly #1 on the right team.   5-Sign Andy to a one year deal, if he wants to come back.  If he does want one more year, we're looking at CC, AJ, Andy, Phil and someone from the mix of Gaudin, Mitre, or Kennedy.  All 3 of the later options had their issues but I also believe they are all on target to correct the flaws.  I was especially impressed with Gaudin after he had worked out some kinks with the coaching staff.  Mitre has the kind of sinker that doesn't necessarily need 90+ to make a difference, he just has to be used regularly to keep his arm loose enough/tired enough to make the sinker work.  I also think Ian Kennedy has had enough humbling events to make him a valuable guy.  When he came up a couple years ago with a chip on his shoulder, it was a misplaced chip...his stuff did not back up his confidence.  I just think he's a different guy now from the inside out.   6-If Andy doesn't sign, I like Randy Wolf as cheap option.  I'd actually love us to sign John Lackey but I just can't see that happening, unless it looks as though the Sox might land him, LOL.   7-You gotta sign Derek for another 3 years at least.  Whether he can play SS for that time is another matter.  But here's another scenario:  Re-sign Derek but move him to left and either use Pena at short or go out and get a FA SS who can also bat at in the 2 hole.  Pena has the defense and showed signs of offensive capability so personally, I'd be okay with him at short.   8-We have the makings of a long term, absolutely terrific bullpen.  Roberston, Coke, Marte, Bruney (yes, Bruney), Aceves, and Mo.  I'll take that group right now against any other team in the world.  And this equation does not even contain Melancon, who I believe will be a very valuable piece as time moves forward.   9-Sign Tim McCarver to an exclusive YES network contract and then have him be the minor league broadcaster, as that seems where his talents seem most fitting.   Mike in Upstate NY, where we'll have temps in upper 60's with lots of sunshine today, the last hurrah before the long night of winter sets in...on the upside, I saw a nice 4 point buck on the way to church last night. -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter@ inbox.com> To: Yankeesmvp1 Group <yankeesmvp1@ yahoogroups. com> Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 7:18 am Subject: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   There seems to be one thread running through a lot of the articles I'm reading, and it has the Yankees picking up Figgins and putting him in LF.  Surely we have someone on the minor league staff somewhere as good or better than him?  He is a Yankees killer,, but he doesn't play that well against the other teams.  Plus I hate the way he spells his first name.  Just can't stand it. Light travels faster than sound. That is why some people appear bright until you hear them speak. Congratulations Yankees! Championship #27! Scott -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter ____________ _________ _________ _________ _________ __ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail. yahoo.com -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter

 

I completely forgot about Johnny's injury in game 6. Good points, Scott.

On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 10:05 PM, Scott Coulter <scott.coulter@...> wrote:

 

I don't think anyone is trading Cano.

 

As for Johhny in LF, I don't think Figgins is really the answer, it was just a thread that was developing in the rumor mill.

 

However, I'm not sure Johnny is either.  Johnny next year will probably be a part-time player if he stays with the Yankees.  His legs are starting to go.  Remember that he was done half way through game 6 of the WS.  If there was a game 7 he would not have been able to play.  Once the legs start to go a player is pretty much done.  Johnny hung on and won one with us.  That may be it.  I would foresee him as more of a liability next year.  I see Hideki as less but I really do wish he was a switch hitter.  I wish one of them was, that would make the choice easier.

 

There are other options for LF and quite frankly this year is a particularly weak free agent class, and that is why Figgins is even getting any play at all.  The best solution may very well be from within!  If we got a chance at Jason Bay I would do that pretty quickly, but other than that, no thanks.  That Holliday guy came over to the AL and couldn't hit worth a lick and then went back to the NL and was good again for the Cards.  They may be his best option.  We'll see.

 

 

Light travels faster than sound. That is why some people appear bright until you hear them speak.

Congratulations Yankees! Championship #27!
Scott

-----Original Message-----
From: alemro13@...
Sent: Mon, 9 Nov 2009 17:41:20 -0500
To: yankeesmvp1@yahoogroups.com
Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?

 

You know Red, I have been saying for 2 seasons that we need someone in LF with a better arm...but now all of a sudden, I want Johnny to stay. I don't know why. I mean his arm is pretty weak, but he hasn't seemed to be a liability at all....I think he'd be fine another year, and I love him in the 2 spot. I think we need 1 more decent starter, and they could win it again with the guys they have. (Two more if Andy decides to retire.) And Joba needs to be in the pen. I mean, come on. I haven't heard anything said about that yet, but before he went to the pen this past season, they were adamant in saying he IS a starter. There was mention over on LoHud about trading Cano. My response? Oh HELL no!!!

On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 5:33 PM, redbug <redbug51@...> wrote:

 

I'm about 5 emails behind you guys on Figgins but had one question...How's his arm?  Because it's hard to beat Johnny offensively and on the basepaths (I think his double steal was the Series).  Johnny's arm is his only majoe weakness.  If Figgins isn't a huge upgrade over Johnny in the field, why replace him? --- On Mon, 11/9/09, mikeman341@... <mikeman341@...> wrote: From: mikeman341@... <mikeman341@...> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@yahoogroups.com Date: Monday, November 9, 2009, 10:46 AM   Scott, You're right on both broadcasters.  Joe Morgan's 30+ years of defending his precious Reds as one of the best of all time is boring, misleading and incorrect.  Yes, they won back to back WS all those years ago, big deal.  In the ensuing time the Yanks have won er...let's see here I think the number is 7 WS titles, including 3 in a row and 4/5...but they'll never ever, ever be as good as the Reds.  Gimme a break.  I read somewhere that he is kind of hard to get along with in the prep and in the booth, I'm not surprised.   The Yanks have been preaching 'in house answers' since Cash got the promised control a few years ago.  I'd really like to see them give Pena a legit shot.  I had been eyeing JJ Hardy for a couple of years as a viable replacement for Jeter but he's off the market again.  I also like Tulo in Denver but I think he's signed long term.  I just really like the Pena option.  I'd like to see him get a real chance next year to win the job for himself.   I also like your assessment of Matsui and the comparison to Ruben Sierra.  Plus, Matsui really, really wants to come back to the Bronx.  I really like him as the DH for the next couple of years.   Mike -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 10:30 am Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   McCarver is a problem and so is Joe Morgan.  I wonder if it is because they were players and played against the Yankees for all those years?   I agree that Andy might take his glove and go home a winner, and he was one this year, that's for sure.   I'd like to see the Pena kid given a chance, I agee that as a SH he might do well for us in the 2 hole.  SH are very valuable, and I didn't notice that he had a weaker side.  He played a little OF towards the end of the season in Scranton, and that might not be a bad way to get up here.  I remember a young man named Mattingly who did it that way.  He turned out pretty good! On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 10:10 AM, <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote:   Scott, Yeah, I'd take Andy in a heartbeart over Randy.  I know Andy's family means a whole lot to him and missing his son's games is a tough one for him.  I am not at all sure he's coming back, in fact at this point, I think I'd be surprised a little bit if he does.  He wanted to pitch in the new stadium and help to bring another title here.  He accomplished what he wanted and would be leaving on an extremely high note.  I want him to come back, make no mistake about that.  I am convinced he has at least one more good season left in his arm and he could still be a terrific mentor for some of the young guys.   I like Pena at short and I can't help but wonder how he'd do in the 2 hole.  It would be a huge jump but he handles the bat well and he's a switch hitter.  I don't think we could expect much power but we have 6 other guys who supply that.  But for right now, Derek is the man at short.  Maybe he'll prove all the naysayers wrong two years running.  In the lineup, I wouldn't put him back at the 2 hole for the reason you mention...too many GIDP.   Kennedy is not flashing too bright on my radar but I do beleive he has the stuff to make at the ML level, a good #3 guy especially if you could slot him in between a couple of hard throwers.   Maybe I am being a little unkind to McCarver but there seems to be an anti-Yankee bias in a lot of commentators, not just him.  It also seems like his age is catching up with him.   It's nice to discuss this stuff from a point of winning instead of a point of desperation.  From my point of view, I'd really rather have our issues than say, the Sawx, who cannot keep a  decent SS since they let Garciaparra go and whose outfield looks a little suspect and a lot overpaid in right...plus Big Papi...now, there's a question mark if there ever was one.   Mike -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 8:36 am Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   I agree on letting Damon go.  And I think the reason they clicked, was that it simply got Derek out of the 2 hole.  He hits into too many DPs from there.  I think Johnny is replaceable.  Hideki reminds me more and more of Ruben Sierra, the mature Ruben.  A very dangerous hitter, and he has proven he can pinch hit.  So he doesn't have to play every day and that's great!   Right now I think you might be right.  We just don't have a ML catcher ready to go so it needs to be Molina for a year.  I like Cervelli's spirit, but it may have been his best year!   Hughes to the rotation and Joba to the pen, and don't forget CMW!  He may be available by early season, around May.  I'm not as high as you are on IPK.  Kennedy would have to do a great deal to earn a spot on my team, but if he can, so much the better.  I'd at least have him in spring training and give him the shot.   Andy/Randy?  I'd rather Andy, and I think he will come back for one more, and then I'm sure he's done.   Derek is not done until the end of the season and I've read where he would be willing to wait.  Pena can hit, so I think that is a no brainer.  He should be playiing somewhere in our infield, soon.  But one more year at short and then hopefully the OF for Derek.  I was kind of hoping that a win in the WS this year would make the transition palatable for Derek next season, but looking at it now, probably not.  Who knows?   Love your thoughts about McCarver, but I'd make sure he never got above AA ball.... On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 8:13 AM, <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote:   Scott, I agree 100%, plus during the playoffs he did not seem to have his head in the game at crucial times.  I also hate the way he spells his name, for what that's worth, LOL.   Here's my thinking on the upgrade issues:   1-Let Damon go.  There are enough good outfielders in market that you could even get a good cf and put him in left.  The big thing that concerns me about letting Damon go is his place in the lineup.  His hitting behind Jeter in the 2 hole was a terrific combination that clicked right off the bat.  This is really what we need by way of replacement, I believe.   2-Re-sign Matsui as the DH.  The guy is such a professional hitter and a clutch situational hitter...he would be very hard to replace.   3-Stick with the Posada/Molina duo for another year until a minor leaguer is ready to take over.  I really like Cervelli, to be honest with you but I wonder at this point if he will develop the pop in his bat.  Otherwise, I love the guy.   4-Put Hughes in the rotation and Joba in the pen.  The striking difference in Joba as a starter vs. reliever makes the decision almost a no-brainer.  The only blemish on him was leaving a ball inside to guy who kills that kind of pitch.  Hughes began to trust his stuff and that made all the difference in the world for him.  His trouble in the post-season was that he began to be concerned about the strengths and weaknesses of the hitter instead of pitching to his own strengths.  He has the moxy to be a good #3 or #4 guy right now and will with time move to a #2 or possibly #1 on the right team.   5-Sign Andy to a one year deal, if he wants to come back.  If he does want one more year, we're looking at CC, AJ, Andy, Phil and someone from the mix of Gaudin, Mitre, or Kennedy.  All 3 of the later options had their issues but I also believe they are all on target to correct the flaws.  I was especially impressed with Gaudin after he had worked out some kinks with the coaching staff.  Mitre has the kind of sinker that doesn't necessarily need 90+ to make a difference, he just has to be used regularly to keep his arm loose enough/tired enough to make the sinker work.  I also think Ian Kennedy has had enough humbling events to make him a valuable guy.  When he came up a couple years ago with a chip on his shoulder, it was a misplaced chip...his stuff did not back up his confidence.  I just think he's a different guy now from the inside out.   6-If Andy doesn't sign, I like Randy Wolf as cheap option.  I'd actually love us to sign John Lackey but I just can't see that happening, unless it looks as though the Sox might land him, LOL.   7-You gotta sign Derek for another 3 years at least.  Whether he can play SS for that time is another matter.  But here's another scenario:  Re-sign Derek but move him to left and either use Pena at short or go out and get a FA SS who can also bat at in the 2 hole.  Pena has the defense and showed signs of offensive capability so personally, I'd be okay with him at short.   8-We have the makings of a long term, absolutely terrific bullpen.  Roberston, Coke, Marte, Bruney (yes, Bruney), Aceves, and Mo.  I'll take that group right now against any other team in the world.  And this equation does not even contain Melancon, who I believe will be a very valuable piece as time moves forward.   9-Sign Tim McCarver to an exclusive YES network contract and then have him be the minor league broadcaster, as that seems where his talents seem most fitting.   Mike in Upstate NY, where we'll have temps in upper 60's with lots of sunshine today, the last hurrah before the long night of winter sets in...on the upside, I saw a nice 4 point buck on the way to church last night. -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter@ inbox.com> To: Yankeesmvp1 Group <yankeesmvp1@ yahoogroups. com> Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 7:18 am Subject: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   There seems to be one thread running through a lot of the articles I'm reading, and it has the Yankees picking up Figgins and putting him in LF.  Surely we have someone on the minor league staff somewhere as good or better than him?  He is a Yankees killer,, but he doesn't play that well against the other teams.  Plus I hate the way he spells his first name.  Just can't stand it. Light travels faster than sound. That is why some people appear bright until you hear them speak. Congratulations Yankees! Championship #27! Scott -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter

--

Imagine Peace

--
Imagine Peace

 

I don't think anyone is trading Cano.

 

As for Johhny in LF, I don't think Figgins is really the answer, it was just a thread that was developing in the rumor mill.

 

However, I'm not sure Johnny is either.  Johnny next year will probably be a part-time player if he stays with the Yankees.  His legs are starting to go.  Remember that he was done half way through game 6 of the WS.  If there was a game 7 he would not have been able to play.  Once the legs start to go a player is pretty much done.  Johnny hung on and won one with us.  That may be it.  I would foresee him as more of a liability next year.  I see Hideki as less but I really do wish he was a switch hitter.  I wish one of them was, that would make the choice easier.

 

There are other options for LF and quite frankly this year is a particularly weak free agent class, and that is why Figgins is even getting any play at all.  The best solution may very well be from within!  If we got a chance at Jason Bay I would do that pretty quickly, but other than that, no thanks.  That Holliday guy came over to the AL and couldn't hit worth a lick and then went back to the NL and was good again for the Cards.  They may be his best option.  We'll see.

 

 

Light travels faster than sound. That is why some people appear bright until you hear them speak.

Congratulations Yankees! Championship #27!
Scott

-----Original Message-----
From: alemro13@...
Sent: Mon, 9 Nov 2009 17:41:20 -0500
To: yankeesmvp1@yahoogroups.com
Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?

 

You know Red, I have been saying for 2 seasons that we need someone in LF with a better arm...but now all of a sudden, I want Johnny to stay. I don't know why. I mean his arm is pretty weak, but he hasn't seemed to be a liability at all....I think he'd be fine another year, and I love him in the 2 spot. I think we need 1 more decent starter, and they could win it again with the guys they have. (Two more if Andy decides to retire.) And Joba needs to be in the pen. I mean, come on. I haven't heard anything said about that yet, but before he went to the pen this past season, they were adamant in saying he IS a starter. There was mention over on LoHud about trading Cano. My response? Oh HELL no!!!

On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 5:33 PM, redbug <redbug51@...> wrote:

 

I'm about 5 emails behind you guys on Figgins but had one question...How's his arm?  Because it's hard to beat Johnny offensively and on the basepaths (I think his double steal was the Series).  Johnny's arm is his only majoe weakness.  If Figgins isn't a huge upgrade over Johnny in the field, why replace him? --- On Mon, 11/9/09, mikeman341@... <mikeman341@...> wrote: From: mikeman341@... <mikeman341@...> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@yahoogroups.com Date: Monday, November 9, 2009, 10:46 AM   Scott, You're right on both broadcasters.  Joe Morgan's 30+ years of defending his precious Reds as one of the best of all time is boring, misleading and incorrect.  Yes, they won back to back WS all those years ago, big deal.  In the ensuing time the Yanks have won er...let's see here I think the number is 7 WS titles, including 3 in a row and 4/5...but they'll never ever, ever be as good as the Reds.  Gimme a break.  I read somewhere that he is kind of hard to get along with in the prep and in the booth, I'm not surprised.   The Yanks have been preaching 'in house answers' since Cash got the promised control a few years ago.  I'd really like to see them give Pena a legit shot.  I had been eyeing JJ Hardy for a couple of years as a viable replacement for Jeter but he's off the market again.  I also like Tulo in Denver but I think he's signed long term.  I just really like the Pena option.  I'd like to see him get a real chance next year to win the job for himself.   I also like your assessment of Matsui and the comparison to Ruben Sierra.  Plus, Matsui really, really wants to come back to the Bronx.  I really like him as the DH for the next couple of years.   Mike -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 10:30 am Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   McCarver is a problem and so is Joe Morgan.  I wonder if it is because they were players and played against the Yankees for all those years?   I agree that Andy might take his glove and go home a winner, and he was one this year, that's for sure.   I'd like to see the Pena kid given a chance, I agee that as a SH he might do well for us in the 2 hole.  SH are very valuable, and I didn't notice that he had a weaker side.  He played a little OF towards the end of the season in Scranton, and that might not be a bad way to get up here.  I remember a young man named Mattingly who did it that way.  He turned out pretty good! On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 10:10 AM, <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote:   Scott, Yeah, I'd take Andy in a heartbeart over Randy.  I know Andy's family means a whole lot to him and missing his son's games is a tough one for him.  I am not at all sure he's coming back, in fact at this point, I think I'd be surprised a little bit if he does.  He wanted to pitch in the new stadium and help to bring another title here.  He accomplished what he wanted and would be leaving on an extremely high note.  I want him to come back, make no mistake about that.  I am convinced he has at least one more good season left in his arm and he could still be a terrific mentor for some of the young guys.   I like Pena at short and I can't help but wonder how he'd do in the 2 hole.  It would be a huge jump but he handles the bat well and he's a switch hitter.  I don't think we could expect much power but we have 6 other guys who supply that.  But for right now, Derek is the man at short.  Maybe he'll prove all the naysayers wrong two years running.  In the lineup, I wouldn't put him back at the 2 hole for the reason you mention...too many GIDP.   Kennedy is not flashing too bright on my radar but I do beleive he has the stuff to make at the ML level, a good #3 guy especially if you could slot him in between a couple of hard throwers.   Maybe I am being a little unkind to McCarver but there seems to be an anti-Yankee bias in a lot of commentators, not just him.  It also seems like his age is catching up with him.   It's nice to discuss this stuff from a point of winning instead of a point of desperation.  From my point of view, I'd really rather have our issues than say, the Sawx, who cannot keep a  decent SS since they let Garciaparra go and whose outfield looks a little suspect and a lot overpaid in right...plus Big Papi...now, there's a question mark if there ever was one.   Mike -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 8:36 am Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   I agree on letting Damon go.  And I think the reason they clicked, was that it simply got Derek out of the 2 hole.  He hits into too many DPs from there.  I think Johnny is replaceable.  Hideki reminds me more and more of Ruben Sierra, the mature Ruben.  A very dangerous hitter, and he has proven he can pinch hit.  So he doesn't have to play every day and that's great!   Right now I think you might be right.  We just don't have a ML catcher ready to go so it needs to be Molina for a year.  I like Cervelli's spirit, but it may have been his best year!   Hughes to the rotation and Joba to the pen, and don't forget CMW!  He may be available by early season, around May.  I'm not as high as you are on IPK.  Kennedy would have to do a great deal to earn a spot on my team, but if he can, so much the better.  I'd at least have him in spring training and give him the shot.   Andy/Randy?  I'd rather Andy, and I think he will come back for one more, and then I'm sure he's done.   Derek is not done until the end of the season and I've read where he would be willing to wait.  Pena can hit, so I think that is a no brainer.  He should be playiing somewhere in our infield, soon.  But one more year at short and then hopefully the OF for Derek.  I was kind of hoping that a win in the WS this year would make the transition palatable for Derek next season, but looking at it now, probably not.  Who knows?   Love your thoughts about McCarver, but I'd make sure he never got above AA ball.... On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 8:13 AM, <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote:   Scott, I agree 100%, plus during the playoffs he did not seem to have his head in the game at crucial times.  I also hate the way he spells his name, for what that's worth, LOL.   Here's my thinking on the upgrade issues:   1-Let Damon go.  There are enough good outfielders in market that you could even get a good cf and put him in left.  The big thing that concerns me about letting Damon go is his place in the lineup.  His hitting behind Jeter in the 2 hole was a terrific combination that clicked right off the bat.  This is really what we need by way of replacement, I believe.   2-Re-sign Matsui as the DH.  The guy is such a professional hitter and a clutch situational hitter...he would be very hard to replace.   3-Stick with the Posada/Molina duo for another year until a minor leaguer is ready to take over.  I really like Cervelli, to be honest with you but I wonder at this point if he will develop the pop in his bat.  Otherwise, I love the guy.   4-Put Hughes in the rotation and Joba in the pen.  The striking difference in Joba as a starter vs. reliever makes the decision almost a no-brainer.  The only blemish on him was leaving a ball inside to guy who kills that kind of pitch.  Hughes began to trust his stuff and that made all the difference in the world for him.  His trouble in the post-season was that he began to be concerned about the strengths and weaknesses of the hitter instead of pitching to his own strengths.  He has the moxy to be a good #3 or #4 guy right now and will with time move to a #2 or possibly #1 on the right team.   5-Sign Andy to a one year deal, if he wants to come back.  If he does want one more year, we're looking at CC, AJ, Andy, Phil and someone from the mix of Gaudin, Mitre, or Kennedy.  All 3 of the later options had their issues but I also believe they are all on target to correct the flaws.  I was especially impressed with Gaudin after he had worked out some kinks with the coaching staff.  Mitre has the kind of sinker that doesn't necessarily need 90+ to make a difference, he just has to be used regularly to keep his arm loose enough/tired enough to make the sinker work.  I also think Ian Kennedy has had enough humbling events to make him a valuable guy.  When he came up a couple years ago with a chip on his shoulder, it was a misplaced chip...his stuff did not back up his confidence.  I just think he's a different guy now from the inside out.   6-If Andy doesn't sign, I like Randy Wolf as cheap option.  I'd actually love us to sign John Lackey but I just can't see that happening, unless it looks as though the Sox might land him, LOL.   7-You gotta sign Derek for another 3 years at least.  Whether he can play SS for that time is another matter.  But here's another scenario:  Re-sign Derek but move him to left and either use Pena at short or go out and get a FA SS who can also bat at in the 2 hole.  Pena has the defense and showed signs of offensive capability so personally, I'd be okay with him at short.   8-We have the makings of a long term, absolutely terrific bullpen.  Roberston, Coke, Marte, Bruney (yes, Bruney), Aceves, and Mo.  I'll take that group right now against any other team in the world.  And this equation does not even contain Melancon, who I believe will be a very valuable piece as time moves forward.   9-Sign Tim McCarver to an exclusive YES network contract and then have him be the minor league broadcaster, as that seems where his talents seem most fitting.   Mike in Upstate NY, where we'll have temps in upper 60's with lots of sunshine today, the last hurrah before the long night of winter sets in...on the upside, I saw a nice 4 point buck on the way to church last night. -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter@ inbox.com> To: Yankeesmvp1 Group <yankeesmvp1@ yahoogroups. com> Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 7:18 am Subject: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   There seems to be one thread running through a lot of the articles I'm reading, and it has the Yankees picking up Figgins and putting him in LF.  Surely we have someone on the minor league staff somewhere as good or better than him?  He is a Yankees killer,, but he doesn't play that well against the other teams.  Plus I hate the way he spells his first name.  Just can't stand it. Light travels faster than sound. That is why some people appear bright until you hear them speak. Congratulations Yankees! Championship #27! Scott -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter

--
Imagine Peace

 

Here is a link to a lengthy but really good article.  I know most of you like the aritcle, but this link is the best I could do.  I highly reccommend this read, it will help us understand what the odds are of certain things happening.  Like, signing Lackey, arbitration for Damon, and moving forward from there.  Good strategy.  I think, anyway.

--
"You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle


Scott Coulter

 

I know he played 3rd but I can't remember his arm.  He hasn't played much outfield in recent yr's. Probably because they neeeded him at 3rd. --- On Mon, 11/9/09, Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@...> wrote: From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@...> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@yahoogroups.com Date: Monday, November 9, 2009, 9:38 PM   I'm speaking strictly to his arm, nothing else.  He played 3rd base all season, probably one of the most demanding throwing positions on the field along with RF. On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 5:33 PM, redbug <redbug51@yahoo. com> wrote:   I'm about 5 emails behind you guys on Figgins but had one question...How's his arm?  Because it's hard to beat Johnny offensively and on the basepaths (I think his double steal was the Series).  Johnny's arm is his only majoe weakness.  If Figgins isn't a huge upgrade over Johnny in the field, why replace him? --- On Mon, 11/9/09, mikeman341@writeme. com <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote: From: mikeman341@writeme. com <mikeman341@writeme. com> Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins? To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Date: Monday, November 9, 2009, 10:46 AM   Scott, You're right on both broadcasters.  Joe Morgan's 30+ years of defending his precious Reds as one of the best of all time is boring, misleading and incorrect.  Yes, they won back to back WS all those years ago, big deal.  In the ensuing time the Yanks have won er...let's see here I think the number is 7 WS titles, including 3 in a row and 4/5...but they'll never ever, ever be as good as the Reds.  Gimme a break.  I read somewhere that he is kind of hard to get along with in the prep and in the booth, I'm not surprised.   The Yanks have been preaching 'in house answers' since Cash got the promised control a few years ago.  I'd really like to see them give Pena a legit shot.  I had been eyeing JJ Hardy for a couple of years as a viable replacement for Jeter but he's off the market again.  I also like Tulo in Denver but I think he's signed long term.  I just really like the Pena option.  I'd like to see him get a real chance next year to win the job for himself.   I also like your assessment of Matsui and the comparison to Ruben Sierra.  Plus, Matsui really, really wants to come back to the Bronx.  I really like him as the DH for the next couple of years.   Mike -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 10:30 am Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   McCarver is a problem and so is Joe Morgan.  I wonder if it is because they were players and played against the Yankees for all those years?   I agree that Andy might take his glove and go home a winner, and he was one this year, that's for sure.   I'd like to see the Pena kid given a chance, I agee that as a SH he might do well for us in the 2 hole.  SH are very valuable, and I didn't notice that he had a weaker side.  He played a little OF towards the end of the season in Scranton, and that might not be a bad way to get up here.  I remember a young man named Mattingly who did it that way.  He turned out pretty good! On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 10:10 AM, <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote:   Scott, Yeah, I'd take Andy in a heartbeart over Randy.  I know Andy's family means a whole lot to him and missing his son's games is a tough one for him.  I am not at all sure he's coming back, in fact at this point, I think I'd be surprised a little bit if he does.  He wanted to pitch in the new stadium and help to bring another title here.  He accomplished what he wanted and would be leaving on an extremely high note.  I want him to come back, make no mistake about that.  I am convinced he has at least one more good season left in his arm and he could still be a terrific mentor for some of the young guys.   I like Pena at short and I can't help but wonder how he'd do in the 2 hole.  It would be a huge jump but he handles the bat well and he's a switch hitter.  I don't think we could expect much power but we have 6 other guys who supply that.  But for right now, Derek is the man at short.  Maybe he'll prove all the naysayers wrong two years running.  In the lineup, I wouldn't put him back at the 2 hole for the reason you mention...too many GIDP.   Kennedy is not flashing too bright on my radar but I do beleive he has the stuff to make at the ML level, a good #3 guy especially if you could slot him in between a couple of hard throwers.   Maybe I am being a little unkind to McCarver but there seems to be an anti-Yankee bias in a lot of commentators, not just him.  It also seems like his age is catching up with him.   It's nice to discuss this stuff from a point of winning instead of a point of desperation.  From my point of view, I'd really rather have our issues than say, the Sawx, who cannot keep a  decent SS since they let Garciaparra go and whose outfield looks a little suspect and a lot overpaid in right...plus Big Papi...now, there's a question mark if there ever was one.   Mike -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter2@ gmail.com> To: YankeesMVP1@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 8:36 am Subject: Re: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   I agree on letting Damon go.  And I think the reason they clicked, was that it simply got Derek out of the 2 hole.  He hits into too many DPs from there.  I think Johnny is replaceable.  Hideki reminds me more and more of Ruben Sierra, the mature Ruben.  A very dangerous hitter, and he has proven he can pinch hit.  So he doesn't have to play every day and that's great!   Right now I think you might be right.  We just don't have a ML catcher ready to go so it needs to be Molina for a year.  I like Cervelli's spirit, but it may have been his best year!   Hughes to the rotation and Joba to the pen, and don't forget CMW!  He may be available by early season, around May.  I'm not as high as you are on IPK.  Kennedy would have to do a great deal to earn a spot on my team, but if he can, so much the better.  I'd at least have him in spring training and give him the shot.   Andy/Randy?  I'd rather Andy, and I think he will come back for one more, and then I'm sure he's done.   Derek is not done until the end of the season and I've read where he would be willing to wait.  Pena can hit, so I think that is a no brainer.  He should be playiing somewhere in our infield, soon.  But one more year at short and then hopefully the OF for Derek.  I was kind of hoping that a win in the WS this year would make the transition palatable for Derek next season, but looking at it now, probably not.  Who knows?   Love your thoughts about McCarver, but I'd make sure he never got above AA ball.... On Mon, Nov 9, 2009 at 8:13 AM, <mikeman341@writeme. com> wrote:   Scott, I agree 100%, plus during the playoffs he did not seem to have his head in the game at crucial times.  I also hate the way he spells his name, for what that's worth, LOL.   Here's my thinking on the upgrade issues:   1-Let Damon go.  There are enough good outfielders in market that you could even get a good cf and put him in left.  The big thing that concerns me about letting Damon go is his place in the lineup.  His hitting behind Jeter in the 2 hole was a terrific combination that clicked right off the bat.  This is really what we need by way of replacement, I believe.   2-Re-sign Matsui as the DH.  The guy is such a professional hitter and a clutch situational hitter...he would be very hard to replace.   3-Stick with the Posada/Molina duo for another year until a minor leaguer is ready to take over.  I really like Cervelli, to be honest with you but I wonder at this point if he will develop the pop in his bat.  Otherwise, I love the guy.   4-Put Hughes in the rotation and Joba in the pen.  The striking difference in Joba as a starter vs. reliever makes the decision almost a no-brainer.  The only blemish on him was leaving a ball inside to guy who kills that kind of pitch.  Hughes began to trust his stuff and that made all the difference in the world for him.  His trouble in the post-season was that he began to be concerned about the strengths and weaknesses of the hitter instead of pitching to his own strengths.  He has the moxy to be a good #3 or #4 guy right now and will with time move to a #2 or possibly #1 on the right team.   5-Sign Andy to a one year deal, if he wants to come back.  If he does want one more year, we're looking at CC, AJ, Andy, Phil and someone from the mix of Gaudin, Mitre, or Kennedy.  All 3 of the later options had their issues but I also believe they are all on target to correct the flaws.  I was especially impressed with Gaudin after he had worked out some kinks with the coaching staff.  Mitre has the kind of sinker that doesn't necessarily need 90+ to make a difference, he just has to be used regularly to keep his arm loose enough/tired enough to make the sinker work.  I also think Ian Kennedy has had enough humbling events to make him a valuable guy.  When he came up a couple years ago with a chip on his shoulder, it was a misplaced chip...his stuff did not back up his confidence.  I just think he's a different guy now from the inside out.   6-If Andy doesn't sign, I like Randy Wolf as cheap option.  I'd actually love us to sign John Lackey but I just can't see that happening, unless it looks as though the Sox might land him, LOL.   7-You gotta sign Derek for another 3 years at least.  Whether he can play SS for that time is another matter.  But here's another scenario:  Re-sign Derek but move him to left and either use Pena at short or go out and get a FA SS who can also bat at in the 2 hole.  Pena has the defense and showed signs of offensive capability so personally, I'd be okay with him at short.   8-We have the makings of a long term, absolutely terrific bullpen.  Roberston, Coke, Marte, Bruney (yes, Bruney), Aceves, and Mo.  I'll take that group right now against any other team in the world.  And this equation does not even contain Melancon, who I believe will be a very valuable piece as time moves forward.   9-Sign Tim McCarver to an exclusive YES network contract and then have him be the minor league broadcaster, as that seems where his talents seem most fitting.   Mike in Upstate NY, where we'll have temps in upper 60's with lots of sunshine today, the last hurrah before the long night of winter sets in...on the upside, I saw a nice 4 point buck on the way to church last night. -----Original Message----- From: Scott Coulter <scott.coulter@ inbox.com> To: Yankeesmvp1 Group <yankeesmvp1@ yahoogroups. com> Sent: Mon, Nov 9, 2009 7:18 am Subject: [YankeesMVP1] Figgins?   There seems to be one thread running through a lot of the articles I'm reading, and it has the Yankees picking up Figgins and putting him in LF.  Surely we have someone on the minor league staff somewhere as good or better than him?  He is a Yankees killer,, but he doesn't play that well against the other teams.  Plus I hate the way he spells his first name.  Just can't stand it. Light travels faster than sound. That is why some people appear bright until you hear them speak. Congratulations Yankees! Championship #27! Scott -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter -- "You don't realize how easy this game is until you get up in that broadcasting booth." -- Mickey Mantle Scott Coulter

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
http://mail.yahoo.com